Inside the Shakespeare archive at the centre of a growing row

News imageGetty Images A man's face peers over the edge of a tabletop beside a weathered human skull. The skull sits in the left foreground, while the man, who has short curly hair, is positioned on the right. The image is lit with cool blue tones, with a blurred background that draws attention to the contrast between the skull and the person's face.Getty Images
Samuel West became involved with the Shakespeare Institute when he performed as Hamlet in Stratford-upon-Avon in 2001

In a library in Stratford-upon-Avon sits a collection of annotated scripts, rehearsal notes, stage designs, letters and photographs that chart decades of Britain's theatrical history.

Its shelves hold traces of actors, directors and productions that have shaped how generations have understood Shakespeare's work.

Most visitors to the town come for the playwright's birthplace or the Royal Shakespeare Company (RSC). Few will ever see the archive housed at the Shakespeare Institute.

Yet it has suddenly become the focus of a national campaign.

Plans to move the institute from Stratford-upon-Avon to Birmingham prompted opposition from actors, academics and former students, with the University of Birmingham ultimately pausing the proposal while it considers the institute's future.

At the centre of the debate is not only a postgraduate research centre, but a collection that supporters argue belongs in the town most closely associated with England's greatest writer.

News imageShakespeare Institute, University of Birmingham A printed page from a theatre script is shown with extensive handwritten annotations in the margins and between lines of text. The page is headed “Act 1, Scene 2” and includes dialogue from Richard II, with character names such as Henry Bolingbroke, Thomas Mowbray and King Richard II. Several passages are highlighted, underlined, circled and crossed out, while handwritten notes cover much of the right-hand margin.Shakespeare Institute, University of Birmingham
The Shakespeare Institute's Samuel West Collection includes the actor's annotated and highlighted Hamlet script and three production notebooks, as well as notes from roles elsewhere

The library at Mason Croft opened in 1995 following a fundraising campaign led by Dame Judi Dench and Sir Kenneth Branagh.

Today it contains about 60,000 volumes, including rare books and what the university says is the country's largest single collection of Shakespeare criticism.

Alongside the books sit archives documenting generations of Shakespeare performance, from prompt books and production photographs to heavily annotated scripts and personal papers.

"This is material unavailable anywhere else," said Shakespeare Institute director Michael Dobson.

"The raw material of cultural history."

News imageGetty Images A man and a woman pose together for a black-and-white portrait against a plain light-coloured background. The man is wearing a suit jacket and tie and stands behind the woman, resting an arm around her shoulders. She wears a light-coloured cardigan over a collared shirt and has her arms folded across their chest. Both are looking towards the camera.Getty Images
Actors Sir Kenneth Branagh and Dame Judi Dench worked together at the Renaissance Theatre Company and also to fundraise for the Shakespeare Institute's library

Among the collections is a record of actor Samuel West's work on productions including Hamlet, Richard II and Twelfth Night.

West first visited the Shakespeare Institute in 2001 while researching the title role in the RSC's production of Hamlet.

"There was a wonderful cross-fertilization between the academics and the rehearsal room," he said.

"It's always been part of my life ever since, when Michael said, 'look, those scripts of Hamlet that are so scribbled on, and those workbooks you've got that you think are sort of silly and no one else will understand. Can we look after them for you?'

"Since then, dozens of people have said that they've looked at my Hamlet workbooks, and my Richard II workbooks, and my Malvolio workbooks, and said that it's been another way of getting into the play."

The archive includes West's heavily annotated Hamlet script, production notebooks and notes from other roles.

News imageShakespeare Institute, University of Birmingham A theatre programme for a 1979 Birmingham Repertory Theatre production of The Duchess of Malfi is displayed alongside several brown envelopes and a handwritten note on a dark surface. The bright pink programme lists cast members including Janet Suzman, Peter Eyre, Charles Kay, Bernard Lloyd and Ian McDiarmid, with performance dates from 3 to 26 May 1979. To the right, four addressed envelopes bearing London postmarks are stacked together. In front of them is a small folded note with handwritten text that reads: "I never read these reviews - prob just as well!"Shakespeare Institute, University of Birmingham
Dame Janet Suzman's archive includes unopened reviews and a note saying, "I never read these"

Elsewhere are records from the Open Air Theatre at Regent's Park, including photographs of a young Ralph Fiennes in his first role after drama school, playing Cobweb in A Midsummer Night's Dream.

There are also photographs of Felicity Kendal, correspondence from Sir John Gielgud and Nigel Hawthorne's personal script from a production of King Lear staged in Stratford-upon-Avon between 1999 and 2000.

"One of the great special things about our library is that it records the backstage details of performing Shakespeare," Dobson said.

"Scribbled notes by actors and directors, anecdotes of playgoing in diaries.

"To understand Shakespeare's art, you need to understand the day-to-day business of showbusiness, as he did.

"The notes made during rehearsals are superb eyewitness testimony to how Shakespeare's plays are brought to life in successive moments and places."

News imageGetty Images A woman standing indoors in a pub, wearing a coral-pink outfit with a long floral-patterned sheer overlayer in shades of pink and red. She is facing the camera and several other people are visible in the background under warm indoor lighting.Getty Images
Dame Janet Suzman, whose RSC work spanned decades, also opposes the move of the Shakespeare Institute to the University of Birmingham's main campus in Edgbaston

Another archive charts the career of Dame Janet Suzman, whose work with the Royal Shakespeare Company spanned decades.

Among its contents are costume designs, production papers and a series of unopened review envelopes from 1979 accompanied by a handwritten note that reads: "I never read these reviews - prob just as well!"

Suzman is among those who have opposed plans to move the institute to the university's main campus in Edgbaston.

The university has pledged to keep the collection together, whether it ultimately remains in Stratford-upon-Avon or moves to Birmingham.

"None of it will be disposed of," a spokesperson said.

"That was true in our original thinking, under which the library would have moved to Edgbaston as a single collection.

"We take our responsibility for it very seriously, and anyone who has deposited material with the library will be consulted about its care."

News imageShakespeare Institute, University of Birmingham Two costume design sketches are shown side by side on a sheet of paper, each heavily annotated with handwritten notes in pencil and red ink. The left sketch depicts a long, flowing robe decorated with snake motifs and Egyptian-inspired symbols, with notes referring to a breast ornament, a snake bracelet and a kaftan. The right sketch shows a figure wearing an elaborate headdress, scaled armour-like clothing and decorative jewellery, with annotations suggesting costume adjustments and additional details. Notes at the top reference scenes from a stage production, while arrows and comments throughout the page indicate revisions to the designs.Shakespeare Institute, University of Birmingham
Costume designs for a production of Cleopatra directed by Janet Suzman in 2010

But Dobson fears the archive could be disrupted by any relocation and argues it belongs in Shakespeare's birthplace.

"Moving libraries is a perilous business," he said.

"Some of these materials are only lodged with us by theatre-makers who continue to own them, and they might well prefer them to be in Stratford, where other Shakespearean theatre-makers can readily consult them."

News imageShakespeare Institute, University of Birmingham A narrow library aisle stretches into the distance between two tall rows of bookshelves filled with books of varying sizes and colours. The shelves run parallel on either side of a grey carpeted walkway. Overhead fluorescent lights illuminate the space, while the far end of the aisle appears slightly out of focus. The books are neatly arranged with visible spine labels, and wooden shelf ends frame the foreground. A small sign and a blue stool are visible further down the aisle.Shakespeare Institute, University of Birmingham
The modern Shakespeare Institute library was built after a fundraising campaign in 1995

Household names including Dench, Fiennes, Sir Stephen Fry and Kim Cattrall have signed an open letter urging the university not merely to pause the move, but to reverse it altogether.

Campaigners, including West, are due to hold an emergency meeting on Sunday as they consider their next steps.

For them, the question is not simply where a library should be housed. It is whether a collection built over decades around Shakespeare's birthplace should remain there for future generations of actors, scholars and theatregoers.

Follow BBC Coventry & Warwickshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.