What the Birmingham flag injunction means
Press AssociationFor months, thousands of St George's and Union Jack flags have lined lamp-posts, bridges and roadsides across parts of Birmingham, becoming one of the city's most visible and debated talking points.
Now Birmingham City Council has secured a High Court injunction aimed at stopping flags being attached to street furniture and highway infrastructure, arguing they pose a safety risk and contribute to tensions and disorder.
The ruling has prompted claims British flags are being banned in Birmingham, but the judge who granted the injunction has stressed that is not what the order does.
Here is what the injunction actually means for residents, businesses and community groups.
What has Birmingham City Council's injunction done?
The authority's interim injunction prevents people from attaching unauthorised flags to street furniture and highway infrastructure across the city, with a penalty of up to two years in prison.
The legal action followed the appearance of thousands of St George's and Union Jack flags on lamp-posts, bridges and other roadside structures earlier this year, with many associated with campaign group Raise The Colours.
The injunction was granted against Raise The Colours co-founder Ryan Bridge, fellow supporter Ben Cullen and other "persons unknown" who have attached, or intend to attach, flags to street furniture in Birmingham.
It will remain in force until either a further court order to extend it or a trial if the council pursued a permanent injunction.
While no date has been set, the court heard any future trial could involve several days of evidence.
Why did the council seek the injunction?
The council argued unauthorised flags attached to highway infrastructure could create safety risks, obstruct visibility and interfere with council assets.
Court documents also referred to incidents allegedly linked to the displays, including reports of intimidation, harassment and obstruction.
During the hearing, the court was told one man suffered a broken leg after being run over by a cherry picker while flags were being put up.
The council also referred to allegations people had been assaulted or threatened in incidents connected to the displays.
Birmingham City Council argued the injunction was needed to protect public safety and prevent further disorder.
It has said it spent almost £170,000 this year removing the flags from lamp-posts.
Press AssociationCan I still fly flags outside my home?
The flags are not banned from display altogether, and judge Emma Kelly directly addressed that issue when granting the injunction.
She said: "The interim injunction needs to be understood for what it is. It is not the court nor the claimant banning the Union Jack or the display of Pride flags or anything of the like."
The injunction does not prevent people from displaying flags on private property.
Residents can continue to fly flags from their homes, while businesses, landlords, pubs and community venues can also display them on buildings or land they own, occupy or have permission to use.
The council has stressed the legal action relates specifically to the unauthorised attachment of items to street furniture and highway infrastructure.
What is no longer allowed?
The injunction targets flags attached without permission to the following public infrastructure:
- Lamp-posts
- Bridges
- Traffic signs
- Roadside barriers
- Other council-owned highway assets
It states people are prohibited from attaching flags, instructing or encouraging others to do so, or interfering with contractors seeking to remove them.
During Thursday's hearing, Bridge asked the court for clarification over the use of the word "encouragement" within the order.
He argued ordinary people might be unclear about what behaviour could be covered by the injunction and told the court: "If I say, 'your flag looks nice', I could be encouraging somebody and go to jail for two years."
Judge Emma Kelly said the term was routinely used in injunctions and that it would be for the court to decide, based on the facts of each case, whether somebody's actions amounted to encouragement.
She added attempting to define every term in the order could actually make it less clear.
Press AssociationWhat happens if the injunction is breached?
Birmingham City Council said anyone who breached the injunction could be imprisoned for up to two years, fined, or have their assets seized for contempt of court.
The judge also granted a power of arrest against Ryan Bridge and "persons unknown", meaning police could arrest someone without a warrant if they reasonably suspected the order had been breached.
Follow BBC Birmingham on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
