Calls for whistle-blower debate to be held earlier
BBCA minister has been asked to bring forward a whistle-blowing law for debate after a unanimous Jersey States Assembly decision.
A total of 42 politicians voted in favour of the motion to bring forward the debate to no later than 31 January 2027.
Carina Alves, who put forward the motion, said she wanted to make sure a previous decision from 2023 was enacted, saying that people should be encouraged to raise concerns and ensuring they had protection when they did so.
Social Security Minister Elaine Millar said bringing forward the law for debate "would not be helpful" and could lead to ineffective legislation.
Millar said: "As the report accompanying the amendment makes clear, a commitment by this assembly to launch the draft law for debate by 31 January 2027 will not allow any meaningful review of the impact of the new law, in terms of protection for whistle-blowers.
"Bringing this law forward for debate in the time frame envisaged by Deputy Alves proposition, without time for proper review, would not be helpful.
"The worst outcome would be a law that is brought quickly, which is ineffective to encourage whistle-blowing, does not give whistle-blowers the protection they need and puts extra burden on employers for no purpose.
"I understand and support the need for whistle-blowers to feel confident that they can speak up when they need to do so without risking their job or career.
"To achieve that, we need to spend some time in 2027 making sure that any legislation that we can bring forward, provides effective support to whistle-blowers, and is appropriate for Jersey."
The vote came as a tribunal took place elsewhere in St Helier involving social worker Alison Renouf.
After the conclusion of the tribunal, Malcolm Ferey, Vice-Chair of the States Employment Board, said: "We recognise that the issues raised through this case have caused concern, particularly around safeguarding and the confidence people have to speak up. We need to learn from that.
"Work is already under way to strengthen whistle-blowing and safeguarding arrangements.
"However, further work will now be undertaken to review the effectiveness of these measures and identify any additional improvements required.
"This is intended to provide assurance to staff, contractors and the public that concerns can be raised confidently, will be taken seriously, and will be handled appropriately."
Follow BBC Jersey on X,Facebook and Instagram. Send your story ideas to channel.islands@bbc.co.uk.
