Scotland's 'mansion tax' law a step closer as bill published

News imageGetty Images A row of stone houses Getty Images
About half of properties worth more than £1m are thought to be in Edinburgh

Scotland's so-called mansion tax has moved a step closer after ministers published a bill at Holyrood.

Under the Scottish government's proposals, properties worth more than £1m will be put into a new council tax band with higher rates.

An estimated 13,000 homes face hikes ranging from about £700 to £3,600.

Deputy First Minister Jenny Gilruth said the legislation would "further improve the fairness of taxation", but the Conservatives said revenues raised by the tax would "barely touch the sides" of what was required to properly fund councils.

Scotland has eight council tax bands ranging from the lowest, A, to the highest, H. Rates are controlled by local authorities and vary across the country.

Under the government proposals, two new bands would be introduced in April 2028. Band I would be for homes valued between £1m and £2m, and band J for homes worth more than that.

It is estimated that that about 13,600 homes will move into the new bands - 12,940 in Band I and 660 in Band J.

The government estimates that the average council tax rate for homes in Band I would start at about £4,770 a year - a £700 increase on the average Band H bill today.

The average rate for houses in Band J is forecast to rise to about £7,650, increasing to more than £9,300 by 2031-32.

The government is proposing transitional reliefs for properties moving into the new bands - excluding second homes.

Under the relief, council tax increases are to be capped at £1,500 or half of the previous year's bill, depending on which is lower. The cap will be reapplied annually until the home reaches its full Band I or J liability.

The government says the new bands could raise an extra £14m for councils in 2028-29, rising to more than £19m by 2031-32.

While cash-strapped local authorities are keen for any extra funds, the mansion tax would have little impact on overall council tax revenue, which is expected to be £3.5bn in the current financial year.

The creation of new bands will require a targeted revaluation of homes thought to be worth £1m or more, with ministers setting aside £10m for this process.

Administrative costs are estimated to be between £385,000 and £2m.

Existing council tax bands are based on 1991 valuations of homes.

There is cross-party agreement that the outdated system should be reformed, but no consensus as to how that should be done.

The government estimates that about half of homes worth £1m or more are in Edinburgh, with about 1,000 in Glasgow.

The others are estimated to be primarily spread across Aberdeen, East Dunbartonshire, East Lothian, East Renfrewshire, Fife, Perth and Kinross, South Lanarkshire and Stirling.

The government said the new bands were not expected to have a "significant impact" on house sales in a way that would impact revenues from Scotland's version of stamp duty, Land and Buildings Transaction Tax.

Scottish Conservative finance spokesman Craig Hoy said: "Some homeowners could face staggering council tax bills, yet communities will still be watching libraries close, roads crumble and frontline services struggle.

"This is not a solution to the problems facing councils, when the money this will raise will barely touch the sides."

A targeted revaluation of homes has also been ordered in England, with the UK government introducing its own so-called mansion tax.

Under the UK government's high value council tax surcharge, also dubbed a mansion tax, homes valued at more than £2m are set to be hit with a surcharge of at least £2,500 from 2028.

The proposals will need to pass three stages of parliamentary scrutiny before being passed into law.

The Scottish bill includes further measures to increase financial support for people with significant cognitive impairment, such as dementia or a serious brain injury, by backdating eligibility for council tax discounts or exemptions to the date of diagnosis.

The legislation would also give local authorities powers to offer council tax discounts in response to local circumstances such as fire, flooding or other natural disasters.

Deputy First Minister Jenny Gilruth said the legislation would "further improve the fairness of taxation for local services".

She said that "those with the broadest shoulders" will be asked "to contribute more towards local services, whilst responding to the housing emergency".

Gilruth added: "This legislation builds on our progressive approach to taxation, which helps to target investment in economic growth and support cost of living measures not available elsewhere in the UK, such as free tuition, free prescriptions and our plans to extend a £2 bus fare cap across Scotland."