Could the status of Lancashire's two cities be at risk?

News imageBBC A large rock on a plinth with the words Preston Jubilee City 2002 in white lettering. It is on a pavement with a main road to the right of it and some street poles behind it.BBC
Preston is one of only two cities in Lancashire

As Lancashire waits to hear what the future of local government will look like, questions have been raised over whether the county's two cities could lose their status.

Preston and Lancaster are Lancashire's only cities, having gained the designation at different points in their history.

Lancaster was the first, and although it received its original charter in 1193, it was formally granted city status in 1937.

Preston became a city much later, after being awarded the status by Queen Elizabeth II as part of her Golden Jubilee celebrations in 2002.

The city won the Golden Jubilee city competition, beating 26 other contenders, including Blackburn.

News imageAn image of Queen Elizabeth II on Preston's Friargate street. She is wearing a lime green coat and matching hat and carrying a bouquet of flowers. The is a soldier to her left and a man in a grey suit behind her. Wellwishers have gathered to the right of the picture with union flags.
Queen Elizabeth visited Preston as part of a ceremony to unveil it's city status in 2002

Why could they lose their status?

The government is planning a major overhaul of local government in Lancashire.

Under current proposals, the county's 15 councils would be abolished and replaced with a smaller number of unitary authorities.

Both Preston and Lancaster are expected to become part of much larger council areas.

It is understood that unless steps are taken to protect their city status, there is a risk they could lose it because the status is currently and intrinsicly linked to the councils themselves.

There is precedent for this. Rochester, in Kent, lost its city status following local government reorganisation in 1998, when it became part of Medway Borough Council.

This was down to an adminstrative oversight.

News imageMARY AND ANGUS HOGG/GEOGRAPH An image of Lancaster town hall. It has three cars outside and a man walkingMARY AND ANGUS HOGG/GEOGRAPH
Lancaster City Council will not exist under the current local government reorganisation plans

According to council papers published in 2003: "A conscious decision was made by the former Rochester upon Medway City Council not to proceed to make the appointment of Charter Trustees."

Charter trustees are a legal mechanism used to preserve city status in places that do not have their own district or town council.

That arrangement could potentially apply to Preston and Lancaster once the existing councils are abolished.

However, there are also examples of places regaining city status after losing it.

St Davids in Pembrokeshire and Armagh in Northern Ireland both lost their statuses in the 1800s before they were restored by the Queen in 1994.

However, if Preston and Lancaster suffered the same outcome, it would not affect local services or change things like council tax bills.

It would mean they would simply lose the legal right to describe themselves as cities unless alternative arrangements were put in place.

How are cities decided in the first place?

News imageDAVID DIXON/GEOGRAPH An image of the inside of Lancaster Cathedral, you can see the alter and ornate interior. DAVID DIXON/GEOGRAPH
Lancaster Cathedral is also known as The Cathedral Church of St Peter

According to the House of Commons library, city status can be associated with having a cathedral, university, a particular form of local government, or having a large population.

Historically, cities were places that had a cathedral, although these days it is not a requirement for a town to have one in order to become a city.

In the case of Preston and Lancaster, both do have a cathedral, but this was not part of the decision to grant them the status.

For a place to become a city, something known as letters patent is usually used, this is a legal document issued by the monarch on the advice of ministers.

There are no additional powers or government funding for becoming a city, but it is seen as an important part of a place's identity and heritage.

Could Preston and Lancaster really lose their status?

While it could be said there is a risk that Preston and Lancaster could lose their city status during local government reorganisation, ministers have indicated they are keen to prevent that from happening.

The issue has already been raised in Parliament by Lancaster and Wyre MP Cat Smith, who sought assurances from local government minister Jim McMahon.

He said: "The government has heard concerns from places about retaining their city status and has committed to making it a priority to protect them and will consider all available options, including bringing in new legislation if necessary."

Although the precise legal mechanism has yet to be confirmed, both Preston and Lancaster are likely to retain their city status, potentially through the same use of letters patent issued by the King on the advice of ministers.

A final decision on Lancashire's new councils is expected in the new year, and so any arrangements to protect Preston and Lancaster's city status are also likely to be some way off.