Council accuses Home Office over Palestine panel

News imagePress Association Zoë Garbett pictured in front of a bright blue backgroundPress Association
Zoë Garbett, the Green Party mayor for Hackney, said the Home Office had tried to interfere with free speech

An east London council has accused Home Office officials of trying to pressure them into cancelling a panel discussion which featured the co-founder of Palestine Action.

Hackney Council says it initially cancelled last month's event, organised by Tribune magazine, after pressure from the Home Office. However, it went ahead after the council's mayor, Zoë Garbett, intervened.

In a letter to the government, Garbett said she was appalled by what she said were attempts to suppress peaceful assembly and was shocked at the "assault on the right to free speech".

In a statement, the Home Office said it was categorically untrue to suggest it had pushed for the event to be cancelled.

The event was due to include contributions from Swedish climate professor Andreas Malm and Huda Ammori, a founder of Palestine Action, which is a proscribed terrorist organisation in the UK.

Internal Home Office and council correspondence seen by the BBC confirms officials first flagged Malm to local authorities weeks in advance as an individual of concern, before later escalating pressure by discussing options for how to disrupt or block the panel event.

An official said Malm had "made many statements in support of terrorists and direct action", which he denies.

Malm told BBC Radio 4's Today programme last month he had received a letter from the Home Office notifying him that his presence in the UK was "not conducive to the public good", with no further details given.

He said he could not "see any other explanation" for being denied entry than his scheduled appearance with Ammori.

News imageGetty Images Andreas Malm posing during a photocall for his film. He has a short red beard and wears a black beanie hat. He is also wearing a white top. He has a serious expression and stands in front of a black wall on which 'tiff', 'Royal Bank' and 'VISA' are written.Getty Images
Andreas Malm said he had been notified by the Home Office that he would not be allowed into the UK

Malm is a senior lecturer in human ecology at Sweden's Lund University, whose work includes the 2021 book How to Blow up a Pipeline and 2025's The Destruction of Palestine is the Destruction of the Earth.

The academic acknowledged he had previously described the Hamas-led 7 October 2023 attacks on Israel as "fundamentally an act of liberation".

Malm said it was possible these remarks, during a December 2023 talk in which he also condemned the "deplorable" killing of civilians in the cross-border attack, had been the reason for the Home Office's decision.

But he argued these views had been in the public realm for a long time, including when he was last allowed into the UK to deliver a talk in May.

He said he was not a member of Palestine Action, had never publicly endorsed it, nor had he given it any financial support.

"All that was going to happen now was that I was going to have a conversation with Huda Ammori, who is a free person," Malm told the BBC on Sunday.

Malm took part in the panel, which was held on 4 November, remotely.

'History of activism'

The council claims government officials suggested the event could breach counter-terrorism legislation but it went ahead after Garbett intervened.

The Green Party mayor accused the government of putting pressure on council staff to intervene, with the venue operator, MillCo, claiming the government "escalated its crackdown" after Tribune confirmed Malm would be appearing at the event remotely via video link despite the ban.

"Hackney has a rich and enduring history of activism and protest – a heritage that we will defend against any government agenda which seeks to undermine basic democratic rights," Garbett said.

A Home Office spokesperson said it does not comment on individual cases of denied entry.

On the claims made by Garbett, they said: "As we have made clear already, it is categorically untrue to suggest the Home Office pushed for this event to be cancelled."

The spokesperson added the Home Office provides local authorities with all available information so they can make their own independent decisions, which is what happened in this instance.

Ammori told the BBC the broad scope of the Terrorism Act is routinely used to create widespread "fear and intimidation", warning venues and councils were being scared off from hosting legitimate debate.

"The prescription of a direct action group as a terrorist organisation for the first time in British history has unleashed an unprecedented attack on free speech," she said.

The UK Supreme Court is due to review Palestine Action's controversial ban under terrorism legislation. The Home Office has said it will robustly defend against the appeal.

More than 3,700 people are believed to have been arrested in the UK over alleged support of the group. About 2,500 have been charged, though none have gone to trial as the legal challenge to the proscription continues.

The government has broad discretion to bar foreign nationals from entering the UK if their presence is deemed to pose a risk to society.

Listen to the best of BBC Radio London on Sounds and follow BBC London on Facebook, X and Instagram. Send your story ideas to hello.bbclondon@bbc.co.uk