'Serious administrative error' in election count

News imagePress Association A hand putting a folder ballot paper into a black ballot box.Press Association
The Isle of Man general election took place 24 September

The original vote count for a constituency in the Isle of Man's general election contained a "very serious administrative error", with some ballots uncounted and others wrongly allocated, a report has found.

A supervised recount of the Onchan ballots was carried out last week after Julie Edge, who lost her seat in September's poll, lodged a petition calling for the election to declared void.

Deputy returning officer Jeremy Callin, who carried out both counts, said he accepted "complete responsibility" for the error, but concluded it did not change the outcome of the election.

In his report to the High Court, Callin said there had been "no failings in the system or the process" because the number of ballot papers issued matched the number counted.

However, he said he believed it was clear from the breakdown of the corrected result and the breakdown of plump votes and double votes that "two sets of ballots were not correctly accounted for in the tabulation of votes".

He said that meant 100 votes cast for Peter Karran and Rob Callister were not counted, while 25 votes cast solely for Rachel Glover were wrongly attributed to Gabriella Corkish.

"This was clearly a very serious administrative error which was compounded by an insufficient cross-check of the tabulated voted to the total ballot papers issued and a failure to recognise the importance of any discrepancy between the two," he said.

News imageJulie Edge, who has long blonde hair and is wearing a blue jacket.
Julie Edge served as Onchan MHK for 10 years

Offering his apologies to the high court and the candidates, he said: "These were errors that were made on the night of the Ochan constituency count and for which I and I alone accept complete responsibility."

He said while other minor discrepancies due to human errors "clearly should not have happened", they had and would "probably occur in any forensic recount of a vote".

The 79 ballot papers referred to as not being accounted for in Edge's election petition to the court was due to a calculation error and all ballot papers were ultimately accounted for.

The result of the recount has not changed the outcome of the election or the result, which saw Glover and Callister returned to the House of Keys- and it was equally clear that Edge had lost the election, he added.

Read more stories from the Isle of Man on the BBC, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Isle of Man on Facebook and X.