School orchestra cuts penalise young people in rural areas, says principal

News imageLouise Aitcheson Gabriella, Louise Aitcheson and Caleb. Gabriella has brown hair tied back, wearing her school uniform - burgundy blazer with blue lining on the lapel, black jumper, white shirt and burgundy tie. Louise has long blonde hair, wearing a green blazer and black top. Caleb has dark hair, wearing his school uniform - navy jumper, white shirt and navy tie.Louise Aitcheson
Principal Louise Aitcheson said pupils in rural areas like Gabriella and Caleb will miss out on opportunities to access music and the arts

Young people in rural areas are are being "penalised" following funding cuts to music in schools in Northern Ireland, a principal has said.

More then 400 promising school musicians have been told that transport to take part in bands and orchestras is being withdrawn as part of cuts to the Education Authority Youth Music Service.

The Education Authority (EA) is aiming to make millions of pounds of savings this year.

Louise Aitcheson, principal of Dalriada School in Ballymoney, County Antrim, whose pupils travel to the senior orchestra in Ballymena, said some young people will not be able to continue with music as a result of the cuts.

The EA Music Service is used by about 20,000 pupils in Northern Ireland.

Fees for music tuition and instrument hire from the service have already risen.

About 2,000 young musicians also take part in orchestras, bands and ensembles run by the EA.

Those from rural areas especially would get transport organised by the EA to take part in practices and concerts.

The towns and cities where the bands and ensembles practiced included Londonderry, Bangor, Ballynahinch, Strabane, Lisburn, Ballymena and Portadown.

However parents have been told that the EA is withdrawing buses and transport from Friday 20 November.

That means young musicians will have to arrange their own transport to rehearsals for forthcoming Christmas concerts.

Pupils Gabriella and Caleb said not being able to access transport to get to and from their music sessions will have an impact on young people in rural communities being able to access the arts and music.

What do pupils say?

Percussionist Caleb is a Year 14 pupil at Ballymoney High School and lives outside Armoy. He drives to Ballymoney and gets the bus to Ballymena and said without transport he won't be able to pursue music further.

"If there's no bus, that would mean me having to drive to Ballymena and back every day. With the price of fuel these days, it'll be unsustainable for me," he told BBC News NI.

Caleb has been offered an audition for the Royal Northern College of Music in Manchester and said everything he has achieved with the EA Youth Orchestra has helped him build towards reaching the level where can apply for music in university.

"If I didn't have that, I wouldn't have the experience and knowledge of music for being able to pursue what I want to do in music, which is going to music uni.

"Without any more of this, it's not going to progress my music knowledge. It's not going to progress what I want to pursue musically as a career.

"I live so in the middle of nowhere, these buses really help to get about and you'll feel stuck when you're living somewhere like I do, without these forms of transport."

Violinist Gabriella is a Year 13 pupil at Dalriada School and lives outside Coleraine. She said without the bus she "just won't be able to go" to music sessions.

"My parents are working and they've got other commitments to do and they just can't really afford to drive there and back every week.

"I won't be able to have the experience of practising such big scores, because in school we do have an orchestra, but we don't get to play Beethoven and things like that.

"Also I won't have the experience of other conductors and playing with so many other great musicians.

"For a musician, experience is everything. Being able to perform - you need that to improve and without that you can't really."

News imageGetty Images A close up image of a person playing the violin. The background is blurred but it includes other people playing instruments in an orchestra.Getty Images
The EA Music Service is used by about 20,000 pupils in Northern Ireland

Aitcheson said the "opportunity that the EA orchestra provides for young people is unquestionable".

"They get the opportunity to work with extremely talented people. They'll develop skills that they won't get the opportunity to develop through school.

"It's just so wonderful for our children to get those opportunities, and the reality is that young people in rural areas really are being penalised whenever there are so few opportunities for young people in many rural communities," Aitcheson said.

"I understand fully that the EA is under extreme financial pressure, but the reality is children are going to miss out, and music is so important in the lives of so many young people but learning a musical instrument is expensive.

"We all are feeling the pressure of finance in our homes, those financial pressures, and the reality is that some young people will not be able to continue with music or access the opportunities that they would have previously if they don't get to access these EA orchestras, so it's really disappointing."

News imageLisa Clarke Lisa Clarke. She has shoulder-length brown hair, wearing a black top and long necklace. She is standing in front of a whiteboard.Lisa Clarke
Lisa Clarke is the head of music at Mount Lourdes Grammar School in Enniskillen, County Fermanagh

Lisa Clarke is the head of music at Mount Lourdes Grammar School in Enniskillen, County Fermanagh, where pupils travel weekly to Strabane for orchestral sessions.

"This really removes access to senior level students in the west of the county to play at a high level," she said.

"It's taking away the opportunity to play in orchestra, in band settings, with other musicians from all over.

"It's really worrying as to what will happen in the future if they don't have something to go to and not anywhere to play at a high level.

"I personally played violin and went to weekly orchestra on a bus every Friday night to meet fellow musicians from Omagh, Strabane and Derry."

Clarke said not having access to transport will have a "detrimental effect on music education" and some pupils may choose to give up on music.

News imageClose up image of Chris Quinn looking into camera. He is wearing a blue shirt with no tie. A door and a white wall seen behind him.
Chris Quinn criticised the suggestion that children should wear more clothes

Despite the need for savings, the EA has withdrawn advice to schools to get pupils to wear more clothes rather than turn the heating up in cold weather, following criticism from principals and the children's commissioner.

The guidance has now been removed from the EA website.

Children's Commissioner Chris Quinn welcomed the decision to remove the guidance and said telling children who are cold in school to "put on additional clothing was wholly inappropriate".

He added: "I am still awaiting answers to the serious questions I raised about school heating, energy costs, the education budget, the impact on disadvantaged children and whether children's rights were properly considered."

In its attempts to make financial savings, the EA has announced that school dinner prices for pupils also set to rise, while it is also cutting a range of other schemes and services.

That includes funding for some shared education schemes, which bring pupils from different backgrounds together.

Quinn said children "did not create the financial crisis in education and they should not be expected to pay for it".