Tánaiste wants border poll criteria talks with London

News imageBBC A close up shot of a man with grey hair, wearing a bright blue suit standing outside. BBC
Simon Harris is due to become taoiseach in November 2027

The tánaiste (Irish deputy prime minister) has said that a conversation between the British and Irish governments over the criteria for a border poll would be "useful".

Simon Harris said he and the Taoiseach (Irish PM) Micheál Martin are "aligned" on the issue.

Adding that it "would be useful at a point in time to understand the criteria that a British government may consider applying to decide whether or not to call a border poll".

It comes after the Northern Ireland Secretary of State Sir Chris Bryant said that it is his job to decide when to bring forward a border poll and that he does not "detect a mood" for it.

Harris said that it would be good if the British and Irish governments "could at least have a shared understanding as to what criteria may be considered".

"At a point in time Dublin and London having a conversation about criteria is useful and is also just good governance," he said

Speaking on BBC News NI's The View programme, he added: "British Irish relations have never been better".

Under the Good Friday Agreement, Bryant as the NI Secretary of State, decides whether to call a border poll or not.

On Thursday morning Sir Chris told RTÉ's Morning Ireland programme he would "only bring forward a border poll at such time" as he thinks the people of Northern Ireland would want to join a united Ireland

"I don't detect that that is the situation now," he added.

Asked what criteria he will use to decide if the mood to join a united Ireland appears likely, he said "when it appears likely".

News imagePA A ginger middle aged man with blue eyes mid sentence in front of a united kingdom flag and gold statue.PA
Under the Good Friday Agreement, Bryant as the NI Secretary of State decides whether to call a border poll or not

When asked why the Irish government should not have a role, Sir Chris said that the Good Friday Agreement is very clear that it's a matter for the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland and that is agreed by the two governments as co-guarantors.

In response, the tánaiste said that "the commitment in the Good Friday Agreement is exactly as Chris Bryant read out, there's no disputing of that. But the application of that is something that would be good to have a greater understanding".

Simon Harris sent a letter to some party leaders in Northern Ireland asking for their views after his party, Fine Gael, published proposals on how to prepare for Irish unity.

The "blueprint" on Irish unity came days after the taoiseach, leader of Fianna Fáil, circulated a document to his parliamentary party laying out his own thoughts on how to prepare for a united Ireland.

He proposed setting up a new "initiative" on the constitutional future of the island of Ireland.

The two parties are both in a coalition government, supported by a number of Independent TDs (members of the Irish parliament) in Dublin.

Simon Harris is due to become taoiseach in November 2027, under the coalition's rotating taoiseach agreement.

What's in Harris' 'blueprint'?

Among their proposals, Fine Gael has suggested appointing a junior minister in the Irish government for "north south relations".

The party also published a document by an economist who works as an adviser to Harris, where it was suggested that the first-year cost of reunification ranges from about €3bn (£2.5bn) to €25bn (£20.8bn) to the Irish exchequer.

His party has now proposed setting up an "independent, government-supported, inter-party and consultative forum" as part of preparations for reunification of the island.

The forum would look at the "future" of the institutions in Northern Ireland and the "possible subsequent reform of local and regional government on an all-island basis in line with the European principle of subsidiarity".

It would also examine the changes needed in Ireland's institutions, as well as public taxation, healthcare, education and other public services and practical requirements.

What has the political reaction been?

DUP leader Gavin Robinson said that his party was "not interested in self-harm and conversations that would see the end of the UK as we know it".

Speaking on the Nolan show, he said that it should be "no surprise to Simon Harris or anyone else that the Democratic Unionist Party, unionists like me, we have absolutely no interest in a discussion about the destruction of our own country".

Alliance leader Naomi Long has said that her party will "engage respectfully" in any conversations about Northern Ireland's future.

Speaking on Sunday Politics, Long said Alliance would take part "without prejudice to how we might decide the constitutional question".

The SDLP leader Claire Hanna welcomed the letter and said "a New Ireland must mean precisely that: an opportunity to build a new nation, not simply reverse partition".

"Crucially, that preparation must also deliver a better Northern Ireland along the way, with stronger public services, greater economic opportunity and better living standards for communities," she added.

The leader of the UUP, Jon Burrows, called Fine Gael's plans a "constitutional pet project" and said that his party "will not participate in any project designed to dismantle the United Kingdom".

"We have no interest in a republican invitation to commit political suicide."

In his response to Harris, Traditional Unionist Voice (TUV) leader Jim Allister said his "courtship techniques are somewhat lacking".

"My message to you is simple: you run your part of this island as your people wish, but butt out of the affairs and future of those pleased to be part of a larger and more prosperous United Kingdom, upon whose defence capacity you are glad to rely," he added.