Church revamp plan at 'impasse' but hope remains

News imageWhitehaven Revival CIC An artist's impression of the regeneration church interior. Food units run around the outside of the space with customers eating and drinking at tables in the central area and on an upper level. A band are playing mucic on a stage at the far end of the room. A number of the building's original features and stained glass windows, such as stone pillars, remain.Whitehaven Revival CIC
The community group envisages the space as being home to a number of traders with an area set aside for live music

A community group aiming to transform a dilapidated church into a food hall says it remains hopeful of making progress despite reaching an "impasse" with the building's owner.

The former Methodist church in Whitehaven, Cumbria, has been empty since the mid-1990s and is in private ownership, having most recently been sold at auction in 2024.

Rob Williams, who as director of the Whitehaven Revival Community Interest Company (CIC) is leading the effort to acquire the property, described it as "needing an awful lot of work" with the total cost likely to run into several million pounds.

Representatives of the owner have been approached for comment.

Williams said the Grade II listed church was built in the 1870s to seat up to 800 people and was in operation for more than 100 years.

He called for further talks to discuss a sale, but acknowledged the two sides were far apart with the East Midlands-based owner wanting more than the £50,000 the CIC has had it valued at.

Regeneration 'catalyst'

"It's become a blot on the landscape," Williams said, "although we think it's rescuable.

"All sorts of vegetation is growing out of the side, it's infested with pigeons and most of the windows have been broken. It gives the area a poor image.

"The Whittles building in the town centre cost about £4m to turn into the Levels gaming hub so that's our reference.

"Without that kind of investment, there is nothing the owner can really do."

News imageWhitehaven Revival CIC The interior of the former Methodist church. Paint is peeling from the walls, which are also dirty and partly covered with graffiti. Some of the stained glass windows are broken.Whitehaven Revival CIC
The building has been unused since services ended 30 years ago

The CIC has looked to Altrincham, in Greater Manchester, for inspiration where an old market was turned into a leisure and eating-out venue.

Williams was confident such a project could succeed in Whitehaven and said research showed a rise in the number of food halls in the UK from 114 to 149 over a 12-month period while the wider hospitality sector had seen widespread closures of pubs and restaurants.

"Whitehaven has just delivered its regeneration masterplan," he added. "This scheme, which we've called The Vestry, could be a catalyst.

"There are a lot of people in the town who were married in the church or were christened there. There's a lot of will to see the building revived.

"The owner's solicitor has confirmed negotiations have reached an impasse for now. While that's disappointing, it doesn't change our commitment to the project.

"I'm staying positive that at some point the owner will be open to sensible offers."

Follow BBC Cumbria on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram and listen to Radio Cumbria on BBC Sounds.