'Clarity needed' over harmed cancer patient support

News imageGetty Stock image of a grey-haired woman with a nurse in a blue gown. The woman is wearing a white medical gown and standing sideways by medical equipment. She is being helped by the nurse who is wearing white gloves. The woman looks nervous. You can only see the back of the nurse's head. Getty
The trust has now reviewed about 500 cases

An NHS trust which harmed breast cancer patients is failing to offer a "consistent approach" to the psychological support provided to them, according to lawyers.

Hundreds experienced harm under County Durham and Darlington NHS Foundation Trust, according to a review of cases dating back to 2023.

Mental health support is being offered by the trust to all those who experienced psychological harm due to its substandard breast cancer care, but lawyer Kudzai Matsika, who is working for former patients, said there was a lack of information about how much support was actually available.

The trust said psychological treatment was by its nature "highly individual and personalised".

Former breast cancer patients who faced harm at the trust are currently being identified through case reviews.

In September, the trust said so far 538 cases had been analysed, with 321 having experienced some form of harm - including one death.

It also agreed to extend its review of cases going back to 2015. Failings discovered so far include delayed diagnoses and unnecessary surgeries.

In September 2025, the trust set up a mental health clinic for individuals affected by poor breast cancer care as identified by the case review.

The trust previously said some of the patients referred to the service showed symptoms of PTSD.

'Need more clarity'

Matsika, from Newcastle-based Fletchers Solicitors, said the patients harmed by the trust she represented had been offered different levels of psychological support.

She said one woman had been offered four therapy sessions but it was unclear whether that would be the full extent offered or not.

Matsika also said others had been told they would get psychological support but had not received it yet, whereas others were still trying to find out whether they were eligible.

"There needs to be a bit more clarity," she said.

Lawyer Hayley Collinson, from Hudgell Solicitors in Newcastle, said the levels of psychological support being offered to her clients also appeared to vary.

She said in some cases, she felt not enough was being provided considering "the life-changing news" patients were receiving.

Collinson said she hoped the trust adopted a "more consistent approach" to mental health support as its review progressed.

In September the trust said that its mental health clinic for its former breast cancer patients had reached "full capacity".

But the trust said it had hired more staff and extended the clinic's opening hours to fix this issue.

"There is currently no waiting list for psychological assessment through the breast review pathway," a spokesperson said.

"We will continue to listen to women, monitor demand and adapt the service."

The trust said an update on the service would be provided at its next board meeting on 2 December.

Follow BBC North East on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram and listen on BBC Sounds.