Detective misled sexual abuse victims, panel finds

News imageGetty Images Two police officers stand with their backs to the camera wearing hi-vis jackets and police helmets.Getty Images
South Yorkshire Police officer Det Con Lindsey Fishwick's actions were found to be "dishonest" and "malicious" by a professional misconduct panel

A South Yorkshire Police officer misled victims of sexual abuse, failed to investigate evidence and gave false information to the DVLA about her former partner, a misconduct panel has found.

Det Con Lindsey Fishwick did not attend a hearing on 5 and 6 November, when the panel found that between October 2020 and December 2023 her behaviour was "dishonest", with a "lack of integrity" that was "likely to discredit the police".

They said: "As such the panel determined that disciplinary action is required in this case."

She would have been dismissed for gross misconduct had she not resigned while under investigation, they concluded.

Fishwick, who worked with victims of rape and sexual abuse, failed to tell a woman who said she had been a victim as a child that her investigation had ended.

She also falsely reported to the force in August 2021 that she had called the woman and "explained the evidential difficulties in this investigation and that it is not because she is not believed".

Her report stated that she had emailed a victim support worker when she had not, while she had "misled" the woman into thinking the investigation was still ongoing.

The woman also sent her a photograph and provided information about the possibility of medical evidence which Fishwick did not follow up.

'Serious harm'

In a separate investigation, where a woman had reported being raped, Fishwick was said to have told her between December 2022 and 21 February 2023 that the Crown Prosecution Service was considering a charge when it was not.

Throughout much of 2023, she also failed to give updates to a social worker and the father of a child who had complained of being sexually assaulted about the investigation and had made false reports saying she had.

The panel found that although Fishwick was "working in a demanding environment" and "had a heavy case load and appeared to be overwhelmed", she had caused "serious harm" to individuals as well as "reputational harm to the police".

They detailed how the woman who made the rape allegation had said: "Dealing with the police and particularly the former officer over the past years had been harder to live with than the actual crimes themselves."

Fishwick was also found to have given false information to the DVLA about her former partner, saying she was medically unfit to drive.

The panel described their relationship as "difficult and conflict ridden".

They described her false reporting to the DVLA as "malicious" and said she "concealed her wrongdoing and attempted to blame others".

The panel said: "Having assessed the totality of the proven breaches, the former officer's service record and the purpose of the police misconduct regime, the panel have determined that the former officer would have been dismissed without notice if still serving."

Listen to highlights from South Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North