Why do construction projects get hit by so many delays?

News imageBBC Two men in high vis clothing are digging up a pavement with a small mechanical digger. They are surrounded by red and white plastic barriers and construction equipmentBBC
Major developments by councils are frequently delayed

It's an increasingly common scenario - a local authority announcing that a major development won't be delivered on time.

Across Yorkshire, key construction projects have been beset by delays, in some cases struggling to progress and ending up years behind schedule.

Councils and other public bodies often have to explain to taxpayers why these schemes are delayed or over budget, and the reasons can be wide-ranging.

One example is Stocksbridge, near Sheffield. In 2019, as part of the general election campaign, the government announced major investment in the town. Levelling Up funding of £24m was promised for a new library and business hub.

Over the following years, the project was downgraded, and work didn't even start on the site until 2025. It is now not expected to be completed until spring 2027.

News imageBen Small A man with black hair is wearing black rimmed glasses and a white shirt. He is sitting in front of a brick all and smilingBen Small
Ben Small from Edge, a consultancy firm for the construction industry

Ben Small is a director of Edge, a Leeds-based company which provides consultancy, programme management, building surveying and technical advice for the construction industry.

Edge works on a range of projects, some expected to cost as much as £100m to deliver. One of the most common reasons given for council-funded developments rising in expense over time is inflation.

"The underlying issue around inflation is what's going on in the wider market which can impact on the construction industry," he explains.

"Often inflation is referred to in terms of what is going on at an international scale, such as in the Middle East, Ukraine and other parts of the world where often materials and supplies are received to feed our industry here in the UK.

"There are elements that impact on inflation on an international scale but there's also a great deal going on much closer to home.

"We often see real challenges within the supply chain, and that could be to do with equipment, services and trades.

"So when councils quote that their project is challenged by inflation, it's often a number of factors that are ultimately outside of their control. Some of those risks are unmanageable by the project team and are driven by external forces."

News imageCity of York Council An artist's impression of historic stone buildings overlooking a road with buses and carsCity of York Council
The York Station Gateway scheme has also experienced major delays

In York, the Station Gateway scheme reached a cost estimate of £60m in July, £34m more than the original budget. The project, which began in 2023, was initially expected to be finished by May 2025.

An audit earlier this year found "critical" weaknesses in the handling of the project. It said City of York Council had entered a building works contract "at risk", which pushed up costs and caused delays.

Small says it can be a long process from the original design stage through to the final construction works.

"In the early stages of a design, the brief may not be as well-developed as an architectural designer might like.

"There can also be a bit of lost in translation between when the architect has finished a design and when it's passed to a contractor.

"It's really important that before an architect's design is taken to market, the client is comfortable with what they are contracting on and everybody is clear as to what is being delivered and for what cost."

News imageThe outside of a railway station with a modern forecourt and glass fronted building.
A multi-million pound project at Leeds Station was also delayed

In Leeds, a milestone in the city's own railway station entrance revamp was reached earlier this month when new steps, lifts and a taxi rank were opened, but the project began in 2022.

The work to the New Station Street gateway was supposed to be finished in autumn 2025, then pushed back to the this summer and again to September.

Small says local authorities need to set timescales, even if they are then repeatedly broken.

"We work with a number of local authorities and the government sector and what often drives a project is the need for it to be delivered within a certain time frame for a certain cost.

"Often a business case is developed based on a set time frame and that drives the investment decisions of a council. That timescale is often quite challenging but if that timescale was allowed to slip it ultimately results in an increase in cost.

"It's really important to have those frank and honest discussions around what can be delivered within certain time frames and doing a reality check as early as possible."

There have been several schemes in Bradford which have gone over budget, including the transformation of the former Odeon cinema into Bradford Live entertainment venue which saw costs more than double from an initial estimate of £25m.

The Darley Street Market development saw its budget rise from £23.5m to around £32.3m, while the One City Park office development, initially estimated at £28.8m was later valued at £35m.

In defence of local councils, the Local Government Association (LGA) says local authorities need contributions from developers to help fund essential infrastructure, facilities and services.

A spokesperson said: "Local authorities seek to spend this money as soon as they can on vital infrastructure, but this can sometimes be a complex process, with the money being held until it can be spent on the project it's earmarked for.

"This is particularly the case for larger and more complex infrastructure projects, which often requires pooling funds from existing and known upcoming developments and co-ordinating across multiple timelines.

"It is important to look at what has been allocated by the council instead to understand how the council intends to spend the money."

The LGA says third parties such as utility companies can also cause delays due to slow sign-offs of plans or their own processes.

And sometimes even the best laid plans hit an unexpected roadblock. Sheffield City Council's Castlegate scheme is £8m over budget after archaeological finds dating back to 1270 were uncovered during construction.

Listen to highlights from South Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North