Murder accused's attack was 'cowardly', trial hears
West Midlands PoliceA pub owner who was killed by a punch to the neck was "quietly and cowardly attacked from behind" by a man with a "fist like a sledgehammer", a trial has heard.
Billy Allison, 36, denies murdering 44-year-old Matthew O'Gara at the Ricco and Loren bar in Lichfield on 24 May, but has admitted manslaughter.
Prosecutors told Stafford Crown Court the defendant, who has previously taken part in boxing matches, deliberately waited for O'Gara to turn his back so he could strike at a "vulnerable area".
Allison, of Shirley, Solihull, also admitted inflicting grievous bodily harm against O'Gara's friend Adam Cooper during the same incident but denies section 18 grievous bodily harm with intent.
O'Gara, who ran The Plough pub on the outskirts of Lichfield, suffered two broken bones and a split artery in the neck, which caused a massive bleed and rendered him unconscious until he died in hospital two days later.
In his closing speech to the jury on Monday, Timothy Hannam KC, prosecuting, described the injury as "unprecedented, almost unique".
It was the kind of injury that might be expected if someone fell from the top of a multi-storey car park or were in a car crash, he added.
He said: "That's not just an accident is it, that's not just being unlucky.
"This is the result of being quietly and cowardly attacked from behind by a man with a fist like a sledgehammer."
SuppliedThe court heard Allison had been drinking in Lichfield with his partner Charlotte Dean and friends, including Ryan Bridge and Ben Cullen.
He had previously admitted he was drunk and had taken cocaine throughout the day.
Hannam said Allison's claim his judgment was not the same as it would have been if he was sober was "not a defence to the charge".
"Just because his judgment may have been a bit off, it does not mean he didn't intend the result of his actions," he added.
Hannam said there was a "thread of events" leading to O'Gara's death, which began with O'Gara shaking Bridge's hand on the dancefloor.
"A handshake that Matthew O'Gara crossed the bar and dancefloor to make, but one that it seems Ryan Bridge did not particularly welcome," the prosecuting barrister added.
"You will remember the roll of the eyes of Ryan Bridge as Mr O'Gara was walking away.
"You will remember Bridge then moves to the corner of the dancefloor and exchanges words with Charlotte Dean and the defendant as he seems to mimic the actions of the handshake."

When O'Gara returned to the dancefloor, he was "clocked and followed" by Allison's gaze, before the defendant "calmly and steadily" stood up, Hannam said.
He told the jury Allison was "no doubt assessing what he was going to do next", adding: "Waiting for Mr O'Gara to turn his back is really important, it speaks to intent.
"Waiting for a man to be at his most vulnerable before attacking with the force used, you may think, goes to the heart of the case. This was deliberate and timed."
Hannam said there was an exchange of words between Allison and Bridge, which lasted a few seconds, before the defendant put down his glass, an action he said was "laden with intent".
"Such an unthinking drunk does not put the glass down so as to avoid hurting his victim too much," he added.
"The defendant carefully and intentionally put down his drink to free up his fists, which we know he was so adept at using, and then we all know the rest."
Hannam said the charges Allison admitted "did not reflect the enormity" of what he had done, describing the incident as a "deliberate, surprise attack".
'No sense whatsoever'
Gurdeep Garcha KC, defending, said Allison was a family man with a good job and responsibilities.
He said the prosecution wanted the jury to think that after many hours of "normal, albeit drunken fun", Allison "suddenly" decided to commit murder.
"They suggest he commits murder in a room full of witnesses, in full view of a number of CCTV cameras," Garcha added.
"He committed murder, they say, against a man he had never met before, a man he had no beef with, a man with whom there were no issues that night, where there were no words, no actions, no build-up, nothing to provoke, no explanation."
Garcha told the court it "makes no sense whatsoever" and claimed the prosecution's assertion of murder "doesn't bear close examination".
"We make it very plain Mr O'Gara did nothing to provoke this violence," he added. "The absence of provocation does not make this murder.
"The fact of a very hard punch doesn't make this murder. The fact that punch broke bones in Mr O'Gara's neck doesn't make this murder."
Garcha said Allison "did wrong" but should be convicted of the right offence.
"We submit the right offence is the offence he has already pleaded guilty to," he concluded.
The trial continues on Wednesday.
Follow BBC Stoke & Staffordshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
