What if a relationship doesn’t feel right?

Should I change to be accepted by a new friend, even if it makes me feel uncomfortable?

This is the question that Tanvi is grappling with in this film, with support from M8-E the robot and her classmates Milo, Emma, Josh and Zayn.

To help pupils consider this question too, why not watch the film as a class to see how the group supports Tanvi? You could then explore the activities to get them thinking critically about how to deal with difficult situations in their own friendships.

Key themes and learning objectives

Tanvi comes into school one day looking and behaving differently to usual. She hopes to be friends with someone new, Sophie, from Saturday Club. However, Sophie demands that to be friends with her, Tanvi has to change the kind of person she is.

M8-E’s alarm bells go off, and Tanvi realises that the friendship with Sophie is making her feel uncomfortable and that real friends don’t need you to change.

This guide enables pupils to explore the difference between healthy and unhealthy relationships, recognise some warning signs that a friendship might be unhealthy and explore how to help someone who might be in an unhealthy friendship.

Learning objectives:

  • I can describe differences between healthy relationships and unhealthy relationships.

  • I can describe ways that unhealthy relationships make someone feel.

  • I can explain what to do when a relationship doesn’t feel right.

Healthy or unhealthy friendship?

Use this film to spark a discussion about how to identify whether someone is being a good friend. Consider creating a list of the key features of a good friendship as a class, starting with honesty, listening, support and safety.

You could begin the discussion by prompting pupils to think back to Tanvi’s description of the weekend she spent with Sophie. You could invite them to select a positive feature from the list and explain whether or not they think that it applies to what Tanvi told the group about her friendship with Sophie. Do pupils think Sophie is being a good friend based on this characteristic? What clues in what Tanvi says and does make them think this?

Emma: “It’s all good. I know you have other friends - I just want them to see how amazing you are. Don’t change for anyone, Tan.”

It may be valuable for pupils to compare a healthy and an unhealthy relationship, by looking at the friendships that Tanvi has with Sophie and Emma. You could split the class in two and task one group to write a list of how Sophie makes Tanvi feel, and the other how Emma makes her feel. Once pupils have completed their lists, you could invite them to come back together and discuss their choices.

During the discussion, you might want to prompt pupils to consider why Tanvi felt she needed to change to be friends with Sophie and whether it made her feel safe. How does this differ from her friendship with Emma? Which one do they feel was healthier?

A cartoon of two school girls chatting. One is holding a pink mobile phone

Expectations of relationships

Some pupils respond better to practical activities, so you could use the scenarios below to challenge their critical thinking with an active brain exercise.

For example, you could divide the room into two halves - a ‘healthy’ half and an ‘unhealthy’ half. After reading out each scenario you can ask pupils to move to the side of the class that they think best describes the friendship. If they are unsure, or if they think it may depend on other factors or perhaps needs more context, ask them to stand in the middle.

There are a few ways that you could support any pupils who are struggling to decide. One way would be to prompt pupils to think about whether the people in the friendship would feel safe, respected and cared for. Another would be to ask pupils on either side, or in the middle, to explain their choices. Hearing other viewpoints on the scenario may help pupils to understand that other people can interpret situations differently to them.

Scenarios

  • Ahmed says Sam can’t be their friend unless he stops speaking to their other friends.

  • Livvy always laughs at the way Kamal dresses, then says, “I’m only joking.”

  • Rahul is often late for school. Jeevan says he’ll call for him every day to help him get ready in time.

  • Chloe wants Mia to go to the park with her after school even though Mia isn’t allowed to. Chloe tells Mia to lie to her parents about where they are.

  • Tia tells Sinead how good Sinead is at cheering Tia up and making her laugh.

If pupils are not able to move around the space, ask them instead to stay in their seats and raise their right arm for ‘healthy’, left arm for ‘unhealthy’, and hold their arms out to the side if they are unsure or think that it may depend on other factors or perhaps needs more context.

A group of girls in blue polo shirts complete a science experiment

How could I help?

If your pupils respond well to the previous scenarios, you might want to give them the opportunity to step into the roles of these characters and have a go at completing the stories.

You may wish to divide the class into small groups or pairs for this and help them to choose which scenario to focus on. They could kick-start their thinking by each writing down one thing that the person in the friendship might be feeling.

If they were friends with this person, what advice would they give them to help them navigate this feeling? For example, Tanvi felt uncomfortable and scared when she was with Sophie. The others helped her understand that this was not healthy and gave her the confidence to tell Sophie how she was feeling.

If pupils are feeling creative, you could invite them to role play how this might unfold. Alternatively, you could encourage them to write a letter, script or draw a cartoon to share their thoughts.

Two boys in red jumpers hug in a school corridor

Glossary

Healthy relationshipA relationship where people show respect, care and consideration for one another, are honest, supportive and good listeners, and make the people in it feel safe and happy.
Unhealthy relationshipAn unhealthy relationship is one where people do not treat each other with respect, care and consideration. They may put a friend down, take their belongings, pressure them to do things they do not want to do or make fun of their appearance or clothing. These behaviours can make people feel unhappy, unsafe or unvalued.
SafeA feeling of security when you are with someone else; feeling able to be yourself.

Warning signs: what could I say or do?

Do your pupils know what to do if a relationship doesn’t feel right?

You can use the scenarios in this interactive activity as an opportunity to practice. You might want to look at the scenarios as a class or assign one to small groups of pupils.

Together or in groups, pupils can work to identify any warning signs that show that the friendship might be unhealthy. Then, they can imagine that it is their friend in the situation described. What advice and support could they give to help their friend to:

a) identify that their friendship isn’t healthy

and

b) know what to do?

More from BBC Bitesize: People Around Us

BBC Bitesize: People Around Us

Head back to the Bitesize: People Around Us homepage.

BBC Bitesize: People Around Us

Bitesize: People Around Us - Film library

All of the resource films and activities accessible in one place.

Bitesize: People Around Us - Film library

Being a good friend

An argument causes M8-E to worry Emma, Milo and Josh’s friendship is over. The group shows how friendships change and how apologising can make them stronger.

Being a good friend

Why words matter

Zayn upsets Milo by using his pet name at school. M8-E and the group discover that jokes can become hurtful, how to set boundaries and how to repair friendships.

Why words matter

Respecting our differences

By helping the group prepare for presentations about their families, M8-E learns the importance of respecting differences among friends, family and others.

Respecting our differences

What are boundaries?

After Emma realises not all of her friends are comfortable with her hugs, M8-E helps her discover how to identify, communicate and respect personal boundaries.

What are boundaries?