But it was a slow start from Thomas Tuchel's side at Wembley and it wasn't until the 24th minute they found the breakthrough.
Kane was involved as he dropped deep and played a chipped pass to Jude Bellingham who cut the ball back for Morgan Rogers to bundle in from close range.
Croatia grabbed an unlikely equaliser in the 59th minute after an error from centre-back Jarell Quansah, who tried to head the ball back to keeper Jordan Pickford following a corner, but left it short and Petar Sucic nipped in to poke the ball into the net.
But Quansah redeemed himself five minutes later as the defender won a penalty after he was adjudged to have been held and pulled by Ivan Smolcic at an England corner.
After a video assistant referee (VAR) check, Kane confidently put the ball down the middle for his 92nd England goal, with 27 of them spot-kicks.
Substitute James Garner thought he added a third late on but Bellingham was adjudged to have been offside before he teed up the Everton midfielder for a low drive past Dominik Livakovic.
Victory secured England's place in the quarter-finals of the Nations League, which take place next year. They will face Group 3 leaders Spain - who beat the Czech Republic 2-0 - on Sunday knowing a win over the world champions will put them top of the standings.