Summary

Media caption,
Watch: PM says decision on Rosebank oil field will be taken "in due course"
  1. Burnham and Badenoch clash on Rosebank oil decision and long-term vision for countrypublished at 13:48 GMT 11 November

    Katie Williams
    Live reporter

    Image shows MPs at PMQs, with Andy Burnham standing at the dispatch box and Kemi Badenoch, seated, gesturing as he speaksImage source, House of Commons

    The Rosebank oil decision and Andy Burnham's long-term vision for the country were in focus at today's Prime Minister's Questions (PMQs).

    It was the first time the two had sparred in the Commons since the Budget two weeks ago.

    Badenoch accused Burnham of having "little vision for this country", accusing the government of being "adrift" and attacking what she called a "do nothing Budget".

    She also accused Burnham of kicking decisions "into the long grass" and failing to set out when the Spending Review would take place.

    Burnham hit back that his Budget was the most popular in a "number of years".

    He also said he was "determined to give the country the stability" that the Tories "failed to provide", committing to presenting his 10-year plan for the country before the Christmas break. He did not set out a date for the Spending Review.

    On Rosebank, Badenoch pushed Burnham for an answer on why it hasn't yet been approved, calling it a political choice after Burnham said it was a "quasi-legal decision".

    Burnham said the decision on Rosebank would be taken "in due course".

    There is a growing sense from many senior Labour figures that it is likely it will be given the go ahead, our political editor writes.

    We're now bringing our live coverage to a close - thanks for joining us.

  2. Cabinet member defends Burnham over government's planpublished at 13:46 GMT 11 November

    Vicki Young
    Politics Live presenter

    Speaking on Politics Live after PMQs, Stephen Kinnock - a member of Andy Burnham’s cabinet - rejected Kemi Badenoch’s jibe that the PM doesn’t know what he wants to do in government, telling me "we’ve got - finally - a leader who’s taking the bull by the horns" on a range of issues including social care.

    Referring to reports that the government has engaged management consultants to work on the PM’s 10-year plan, Matt Vickers, a shadow Home Office minister, joked "six months in he’s got someone to do his homework for him!".

    You can catch up with today’s Politics Live on BBC iPlayer.

  3. Police previously highlighted scores of illegal e-bike seizurespublished at 13:43 GMT 11 November

    During PMQs, Burnham said they are considering tougher regulations on sales of illegal e-bikes, after a question on what the government is doing about them.

    A number of police forces have reported seizures of illegal e-bikes.

    Earlier this month, hundreds were crushed as part of a police crackdown in Sussex and Surrey.

    Sussex PCC Katy Bourne called the operation "a big message" in the run-up to Christmas: "If you're buying these make sure you adhere to the law."

    Dorset Police seized 99 e-bikes and 128 e-scooters across the county in 2025 in response to an increase in reported incidents over illegal e-vehicle misuse.

    Thames Valley Police said last week officers had confiscated 35 of the illicit vehicles in Oxford during the previous week. The force said many of the bikes it seized in the city had been modified to travel at speeds "significantly above legal limits".

    Current government rules, external state road legal e-bikes must have:

    • Pedals that can propel the bike
    • Have a motor rated at no more than 250 watts
    • Stop providing electric assistance above 15.5mph (25km/h)

    People can then modify them to make them illegal, or alternatively, buy modification packs for regular, non e-bikes which then can become self propelled above a legal speed.

    Police can seize illegal bikes, fine the rider and issue points on their licence if they are ridden on public roads.

  4. A bill to widen the census - what are the proposed changes?published at 13:33 GMT 11 November

    Liberal Democrat MP Josh BabarindeImage source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Liberal Democrat MP Josh Babarinde is part of a group of MPs who are trying to create more options on the census

    During PMQs, Lib Dem leader Ed Davey referenced efforts from a group of MPs to create more options on the census which would allow people to define themselves as black English or Asian English.

    At the 2021 census, the ethnic group section saw English offered only within the white category.

    In response, Burnham said he "would want to support that bill to directly take on the poisonous politics that we've seen from some in this house seeking to divide us".

    Liberal Democrat MP Josh Babarinde - who introduced the private member's bill - has called for the categories to be updated in a similar way to changes in Wales and Scotland.

    Babarinde said the "only box that says English sits under the white category".

    He added: "If you are black, the form offers you black British, if you are Asian, it offers you Asian British, but not English."

    His proposal, dubbed the "St George's Bill", aims to broaden the option. Its supporters include Labour's David Lammy and Conservative James Cleverly. It was tabled in the House of Commons on Tuesday.

    Babarinde asked for the bill, formally known as the English Ethnic Identity (census particulars) Bill, to return to the Commons on 23 April 2027 - St George's Day - for its second reading debate.

    But it is unlikely to be considered further in its current form due to a lack of parliamentary time.

  5. BBC Verify

    Is the Rosebank oil field in the Budget as Badenoch claimed?published at 13:18 GMT 11 November

    By Tom Edgington

    Badenoch pressed the prime minister on when a decision would be made about the future of the Rosebank oil field, claiming the chancellor "has already bagged the tax revenue".

    "There’s just one problem, Rosebank hasn’t been approved. If it’s not going to be approved, why was it in the Budget?", the Conservative leader said.

    It’s true that a decision on whether to approve drilling at Rosebank has yet to be made - and Burnham responded by saying a decision would be "taken in due course”.

    As for Badenoch’s claim about it being in the Budget, the oil field isn’t specifically mentioned in the Red Book - the Treasury’s official document, external.

    However, estimated future taxes from Rosebank is in projections for government revenue published alongside the Budget, by the Office for Budget Responsibility (OBR), the government's independent economic forecaster.

    This isn’t a new practice. Rosebank revenue forecasts have featured in official OBR forecasts since 2019., external

    In its latest forecast, the OBR estimates, external that North Sea oil and gas production would decline by around 14% a year to 2031 with no new fields, compared with around 10% a year if Rosebank and other fields were approved.

  6. Burnham questioned on help for oil prices this winterpublished at 12:51 GMT 11 November

    John Lamont, Conservative MP for Berwickshire, Roxburgh and Selkirk turns to the price of heating oil - and asks Burnham what more he will do to help people struggling to pay bills as they are relying on heating oil.

    He says many struggling are vulnerable and pensioners.

    Burnham says he has provided extra funding to local authorities and through the Barnett formula.

    "We have given extra support to devolved administrations," he adds. "There is extra help there the Scottish government can use."

    He says the government will "make sure everybody is supported this winter".

    PMQs for this week has now ended - stick with us as we bring you more analysis and reaction.

  7. Government will 'continue to chase down' small boat gangs, Burnham sayspublished at 12:47 GMT 11 November

    Conservative MP for Gosport Caroline DinenageImage source, House of Commons

    Conservative MP for Gosport Caroline Dinenage says recent small boat crossings in the direction of the Solent have been "spectacularly mishandled".

    She says the government's failure to communicate with residents "bred misinformation" and led to "violent protests". It also communicated to gangs that this has become a "viable new route", she says.

    She asks what message the PM has for Gosport businesses and residents, as well as Hampshire police and taxpayers left with the bill.

    "The message is that we will work with their member of Parliament to particularly hold to account those who caused the damage to those properties and those businesses," Burnham says, adding that the government will provide support.

    He says he understands that Dinenage is meeting the border security minister later today to discuss the issues further.

    He says the government has been successful in stopping small boat crossings, meaning gangs are "changing their tactics". He adds: "We will continue to chase them down."

  8. Cross party cheers for question on e-bikes regulationpublished at 12:45 GMT 11 November

    Kate Whannel
    Political reporter, reporting from the House of Commons

    Cross party cheers for Labour MP Martin Rhodes as he asks the PM to tighten regulations on e-bikes, particularly those adapted to go faster.

  9. Burnham: E-bikes running at excess speeds need to be stoppedpublished at 12:45 GMT 11 November

    Labour MP Martin RhodesImage source, House of Commons

    Burnham is asked by Labour MP Martin Rhodes what the government is doing about the sale of illegally modified e-bikes online and how they will hold sellers to account.

    We are considering tougher regulations, he responds, adding: "E-bikes that are running at excess speeds need to be stopped."

  10. UK putting pressure on Israel to allow aid into Gaza, Burnham sayspublished at 12:43 GMT 11 November

    On the war in Gaza, Your Party MP Jeremy Corbyn asks if the PM will ensure that aid gets to Gaza, and will he support an inquiry into the British supply of weapons and security to the Israeli state.

    Burnham says the humanitarian situation in Gaza is "heartbreaking" and they are putting pressure on the Israeli government "to allow necessary aid into Gaza and lift restrictions".

    He highlights recent UK sanctions affecting goods from the occupied West Bank, and that the UK government awaits the the outcome of ongoing election negotiations in Israel.

    "We will continue to pursue the path we set out" on, Burnham concludes.

  11. Will the UK join the single market? No, Burnham says firmlypublished at 12:40 GMT 11 November

    Ed Davey in the House of CommonsImage source, House of Commons

    Davey turns next to welfare.

    He tells the Commons we can't leave young people "without the dignity of work and the chance to get on", but they also need to bring the welfare bill down.

    The blame doesn't lie with young people, Davey adds, but with the Conservatives who "tanked the economy". Labour has made it worse with the "jobs tax".

    Will Burnham cut welfare, help young people into work and grow the economy by joining the EU's single market, he asks.

    "No is the answer to that today Mr Speaker," Burnham replies, adding the government is honouring their manifesto.

    He agrees young people need support to get into work and that cutting their benefits without that support would be wrong.

    The work and pensions secretary will set out reforms, Burnham says, as the government embarks on its response to the Milburn report next week

  12. Burnham 'would want to support' bill aiming at widening census ethnicity optionspublished at 12:38 GMT 11 November

    Lib Dem leader Ed Davey says politics has been affected by "poisonous ideas" including the idea that people born and raised in England can't be English if they're not white.

    "We must reject it, as the Conservative leader to her great credit has done," he says.

    He says this should start with the census, adding that the only English option currently is white English.

    He references efforts from a group of MPs including Liberal Democrat MP Josh Babarinde to create more options, allowing people to define themselves as black English or Asian English.

    "Will the PM support his bill?" Davey asks.

    Burnham says he hasn't looked at the detail of the bill but says he believes he "would want to support that bill to directly take on the poisonous politics that we've seen from some in this house seeking to divide us".

    Today's Prime Minister's Questions has now finished - we'll continue bringing you the key lines in this page.

  13. Analysis

    Badenoch sought to tease away at Labour divisions on oil and gaspublished at 12:37 GMT 11 November

    Chris Mason
    Political editor

    After the prime minister suggested to The Economist magazine last week, external that his 10-year plan might come in the new year - rather than before Christmas as originally billed - Andy Burnham tells MPs it will be set out before the end of this year.

    Burnham also says it would be set out in the House of Commons — perhaps a nod to ongoing criticisms from Speaker Sir Lindsay Hoyle when big government announcements are made elsewhere first.

    Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch’s questions sought to tease away at Labour divisions on the question of whether permission should be granted to drill oil in the Rosebank field off the north-west coast of the Shetland Islands.

    It is another big moment expected before Christmas, with a growing sense from many senior Labour figures that it is likely it will be given the go ahead.

    The other thing that stood out for me in the exchanges between the party leaders was Sir Ed Davey’s question about broadening out the census options for those who see themselves as English - more on that in the next post.

    At the moment, the only option is white English - Davey thinks this should change, so options such as black English or Asian English are included too. The prime minister says he thinks it sounds like a good idea.

  14. Badenoch presses Burnham on Rosebank oil decision - a recappublished at 12:35 GMT 11 November

    Andy Burnham in the House of CommonsImage source, House of Commons

    Prime Minister Andy Burnham has been facing questions from Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch at this week's PMQs - their first showdown since the Budget. Here's a quick recap of their exchanges:

    Stay with us as we continue to bring you more from PMQs.

  15. Energy secretary shakes head at Rosebank questionspublished at 12:34 GMT 11 November

    Kate Whannel
    Political reporter, reporting from the House of Commons

    Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh shook her head during Badenoch‘s questions on Rosebank.

    She will be the minister ultimately making the decision over whether or not to approve the oil field.

  16. Badenoch will 'have to come up with better than that' to take on Labour plans, Burnham sayspublished at 12:30 GMT 11 November

    Badenoch repeats her assertion that the UK has been left with a "do-nothing budget", a delayed spending review and an "outsourced" 10-year plan - "the whole country is in limbo".

    She adds that Burnham "knifed" former PM Keir Starmer in the back and now "doesn't know what to do".

    The PM responds that he has told her what he is doing - a national care service, bringing down energy bills and fixing the youth employment crisis - and says Badenoch will "have to come up with better than that if she's going to take on what we're putting forward".

  17. Burnham defends energy policy as Badenoch continues to press over oil and gaspublished at 12:27 GMT 11 November

    Andy Burnham in the House of CommonsImage source, House of Commons

    Badenoch repeats that she is asking about Rosebank, saying maybe the government doesn't want it hanging over its head at the COP31 summit, which is taking place in Turkey.

    She says the government is today in court defending its right to drill off the Falklands - but at the same time, the government is passing legislation to ban drilling off Scotland.

    "Why is is acceptable in the Falklands but not the North Sea?" she asks.

    Burnham says his government has recently approved North Sea drilling at Jackdaw, adding the government has today announced two offshore wind farms off the coast of East Anglia and eastern Scotland.

    He outlines measures his government has made such as removing standing charges from gas bills and removing VAT from electricity bills.

    "That is an energy policy. The opposite party could've done one when they were in office."

  18. Badenoch focuses on Rosebank oil decision as Burnham attacks Tory recordpublished at 12:22 GMT 11 November

    Media caption,

    Watch: PM says decision on Rosebank oil field will be taken "in due course"

    Badenoch says Rosebank oil field is a political decision, not a quasi-judicial one, which Burnham just described it as.

    Why else, she says, did it take the Labour government two years to approve Jackdaw gas field while the foreign secretary was in charge.

    Now he's gone, it happened "just like that", she says.

    Badenoch continues, the chancellor is banking the tax revenue for Rosebank in his Budget calculations - "so why won't he approve it?"

    Burnham responds that the approval of Jackdaw was "struck down" under the last government because they "made it an overtly political decision".

    He suggests she should "look a little closer to home" to look at why they failed to take the decision.

    He adds that a further decision on Rosebank will be taken "in due course" and Labour is also working on building a renewable energy future.

  19. Burnham is kicking decisions 'into the long grass', Badenoch sayspublished at 12:16 GMT 11 November

    Kemi Badenoch in the House of CommonsImage source, House of Commons

    Badenoch says she asked Burnham to confirm when the spending review will be. "We did not get an answer," she says, accusing Burnham of kicking decisions "into the long grass".

    She says the Iranian regime is "threatening our bases today but he can't tell us when the government will properly fund defence".

    She adds that there was "one worthwhile thing in the Budget" - the Rosebank oil field. But she says it hasn't been approved yet, and asks why it was in Budget given this.

    Burnham says Badenoch knows it was a "quasi-legal decision" and that it will be "taken in due course". He says the government has approved other big decisions like the Jackdaw gas field.

    He then accuses Badenoch's proposed cuts to welfare of threatening "working people", saying their incomes will be hit hard in the cost of living crisis.

  20. Burnham side-steps question about Spending Review as he defends Budgetpublished at 12:15 GMT 11 November

    Media caption,

    Badenoch criticises 'do-nothing Budget' and delayed spending review

    Badenoch accuses the government of being "adrift", attacking what she calls the "do nothing Budget".

    She asks whether he can assure the Spending Review will come before next summer?

    He says his Budget was the most popular in a "number of years".

    There will be a proposal for a national care service in the 10-year plan, he says, adding they will present the Milburn review next week, which looks at young people and work.

    He does not provide a date for the Spending Review.