Summary

  1. Trump, Xi and Putin issue joint declaration after historic meetingpublished at 15:25 GMT

    Katie Williams
    Live reporter

    US President Trump walks with Chinese President Xi Jinping and Russian President Vladimir Putin as they participate in a trilateral meeting at the Kylin Villa in ShenzhenImage source, Reuters

    Donald Trump has left China after a historic trilateral meeting with Presidents Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin.

    Following the summit in Shenzhen, the countries issued a joint declaration, vowing dialogue on reducing nuclear risks and reforming the UN, and saying they plan to increase supplies of petroleum products.

    Sitting around a very large conference table, the three leaders also addressed the media together.

    Xi said global powers bear "special responsibilities" in today's interconnected world. Trump said "no peace was ever forged by declining opportunities for engagement". And Putin called for constructive co-operation.

    Despite the rhetoric and imagery, the joint statement from the three countries provided minimal substance, our North America correspondent writes.

    Our eastern Europe correspondent, reporting from Kyiv, says that as Putin spoke of peace in China, Russian strikes were hitting the Ukrainian capital.

    Earlier in the day, before the trilateral meeting, the US president spoke individually with Putin and Xi.

    Trump called Putin his "friend" and said the two leaders have had a "great relationship for many years". Watch the moment here.

    Meeting Xi shortly after, he said the US and China have made "significant strides" in improving economic ties over the past year and a half.

    We're ending our live coverage now, you can read more in our news story here.

  2. Analysis

    We've had rhetoric and imagery, but little substancepublished at 15:02 GMT

    Anthony Zurcher
    North America correspondent in Washington DC

    The joint communique, issued by the three nations, is mostly a vague endorsement of efforts to ensure "strategic stability and international security".

    That, along with the visuals of three powerful men sitting in the same room to amicably discuss issues of global importance, might offer the world some reassurance no catastrophic conflicts are on the horizon.

    But pledges of further "dialogue" and an acknowledgement that nuclear war "must never be fought" provide minimal substance beyond the rhetoric.

    A line about boosting "the production and supply of refined petroleum products" seems directed at Putin, given that nation’s role as a major source of fossil fuels on the international market.

    And it was hard to miss the condemnation of the International Criminal Court – which has been a recent target of American ire.

    If there’s one thing the leaders of the three major world powers can agree on, it’s that multilateral global organisations that attempt to enforce international law shouldn’t have the teeth to back up those efforts.

  3. Trump's 'friend' is a war criminal, senior Democrat says of Putinpublished at 15:01 GMT

    Democratic Senator Jeanne Shaheen from New Hampshire photographed during an annual summitImage source, Getty Images

    It's 09:00 EST in Washington DC, and lawmakers are just settling into their offices, seeing the latest news of Trump's visit to Shenzhen, including the US president's chumminess with Xi and Putin.

    Jeanne Shaheen, the Democratic ranking member on the Senate foreign relations committee, writes on X: "President Trump’s ‘friend’ is a murderous war criminal."

    She is responding to an earlier remark from Trump who, as he entered a room and greeted Vladimir Putin, referred to the Russian leader as his "friend".

  4. White House sets out four points the leaders agreed onpublished at 14:43 GMT

    Brandon Drenon
    Washington DC

    The White House has also released a statement outlining the outcomes from Trump's trilateral meeting with Xi and Putin - it makes the same points as the countries' joint declaration.

    "The three heads of state had an in-depth exchange of views on the current international situation and committed to maintaining strategic stability and international security," the White House says.

    It then features four bullet points saying:

    • China, the US, and Russia have "committed to reform the UN" to respond more effectively to global challenges
    • The countries "plan to increase" the production and supply of petroleum products
    • They agreed that the International Criminal Court and other similar entities "must not abuse their jurisdiction"
    • The three countries "will conduct a dialogue on reducing nuclear risks" and preventing nuclear proliferation

    Many observers had expected that Trump would extend America's trade truce with China, which is due to expire in January, but so far there has been no such announcement.

    How the declaration was presented on the White House website
    Image caption,

    How the declaration was presented on the White House website

  5. As Putin spoke of peace in China, Russian strikes were hitting Kyivpublished at 14:25 GMT

    Sarah Rainsford
    Eastern Europe correspondent, in Kyiv

    A street with emergency responders in KyivImage source, Global Images Ukraine via Getty Images
    Image caption,

    Ukrainian rescue workers on Thursday after a Russian strike in the historic Podil area of Kyiv

    As the talks were under way in China, and even as Vladimir Putin was holding his press conference claiming to be ready for peace, Kyiv was under attack from Russian drones.

    We've heard multiple explosions, the air defence guns have been working hard. We've seen black smoke rising from various parts of the city.

    Since the talks ended, the attacks have intensified. Ukraine's air force says Russia is now using jet powered drones.

    We are seeing reports of fires in the Podil area in the city centre. Debris has fallen on at least one building. So far there are reports of one person injured in Kyiv.

    These are the most intense day-time attacks for some time, and the timing is surely not a coincidence.

    In China, Putin was sounding ever more intransigent when it comes to peace talks, claiming that Ukraine was keeping the war going by attacking civilian infrastructure - including the Crimea bridge.

    There was no mention from him of almost five years of Russian attacks on power plants, bridges and houses here in Ukraine.

  6. China summit 'a gift to Vladimir Putin', says former UK foreign secretarypublished at 14:09 GMT

    Jeremy Hunt pictured at 2024 conferenceImage source, Getty Images

    Conservative MP Jeremy Hunt - who held a number of Cabinet positions under previous Conservative governments - has called today's meeting "a summit that should never have happened".

    He tells Radio 4's World at One programme: "It is a gift to Vladimir Putin, who is responsible for the biggest war on the European continent since World War Two."

    The meeting "gives him credibility which will strengthen his position and probably mean that the war goes on for longer," he says.

    What's "even more disturbing" is that it confirms "America is no longer the leader of the free world", he says.

    "There is no other US president in our lifetimes who would have done this," Hunt tells the programme, adding that Trump is prepared to put aside all other responsibilities "to get himself a headline".

    Calling the US president a dealmaker, he says the thing Trump is "really desperate" for is lower gas prices in the US - a key issue behind his party's crushing midterm losses.

    What he's prepared to give is "less clear", Hunt says. He thinks Trump is probably "hinting at some kind of sanctions relief for Russia" - a major energy producer.

    This would give Russia "more money to fund the war in Ukraine", Hunt says.

  7. Greater trust between US and Russia 'could see sanctions lifted', says Moscow advisorpublished at 14:00 GMT

    Vladimir Putin (L) with his back to the camera greets Donald Trump (R). Behind them are two leaders in suit, heads only partially visible from the mouth downImage source, EPA

    Kirill Babaev is the director of the Institute of China and Contemporary Asia at the state-backed Russian Academy of Sciences, which advises Moscow on China relations.

    He tells World Business Express's Leanna Byrne that a "stable connection" between Trump, Xi and Putin is important for communication and resolution to conflicts.

    And an improved relationship between the US and Russia could have a major impact on the future of sanctions, Babaev adds.

    “In case the trust between the two is back, the sanctions can be lifted, and then the two countries can return to full-scale cooperation in [the] energy sector, in [the] agriculture sector, in manufacturing, in technologies," he says.

    "The contact and especially the personal touch between the leaders for the two largest nuclear powers of the world is definitely important for political stability and economic stability as well. It's not only about the bilateral relations between the two".

  8. Analysis

    Optics may be the only lasting impression of Trump's trilateral meetingpublished at 13:51 GMT

    Anthony Zurcher
    North America correspondent in Washington DC

    Vladimir Putin (L), Xi Jinping (C) and Donald Trump (R) sit at a large wooden table inside a carpeted room. Behind Xi are a Russian, Chinese and US flag and a painting of a forest landscape with moutImage source, EPA

    Donald Trump went into his trilateral meeting with Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping with little on the agenda and no clear asks – and it appears that he left with little in return.

    Now that he has departed China, we’re still waiting for his take on how the meeting with Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping went.

    In the end, the visuals of the meeting – the “optics”, as political wags like to say – may be the only lasting impression left by the summit, billed by some as a historic “Yalta 2.0” meeting of great powers.

    The pomp and the ceremony, in the end, may be what Trump wanted most.

    In an interview on Wednesday with Fox News, the American president noted his prominent seating spot at the Apec dinner on Tuesday and his reception upon arriving in China - “the fanfare, the beauty, the pageantry, the thousands of people” – as evidence that the trip had already been a success.

    That might appear to be a low bar, but it’s one that could satisfy the American side.

  9. US lawmakers cast doubt on success of Trump's meeting with Xi and Putinpublished at 13:43 GMT

    From left to right, side shots of Vladimir Putin, Xi Jinping and Donald Trump while posing for official photographs in front of Chinese, Russian and US flagsImage source, AFP via Getty Images

    Although Donald Trump's affinity for Vladimir Putin and Xi Jinping is not new, he's in full charm mode with the leaders in Shenzhen, likely a site of concern for the many lawmakers back home who issued caution or condemnation ahead of his visit.

    Rick Scott, a Republican senator on the armed services committee, said on Wednesday: "Do I trust Xi or Putin? No, they're a bunch of liars."

    "I'm glad the president's trying. Hope springs eternal," he continued. "But do I actually really believe something good's going to come out of it? I don't.”

    Chuck Schumer, the top-ranking Democrat in the Senate, said on the floor of Congress yesterday: "Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin are playing Donald Trump like a cheap violin."

    Nine Democrats on the Senate foreign relations committee signed a letter the same day, urging that "American security cannot be traded away for photo opportunities or personal aggrandizement."

  10. What we heard from Putin as he addressed media after trilateral meetingpublished at 13:34 GMT

    Putin addresses media during press conferenceImage source, EPA

    Vladimir Putin has been addressing media following a historic trilateral meeting with China and the US earlier today.

    Here's a recap of some of the key lines:

    • He described the meeting as an "important chapter in the history of diplomacy", saying the three countries reached a mutual understanding on several key issues
    • On the war in Ukraine, he said Kyiv and Europe are not yet ready to make compromises to resolve the conflict
    • Referencing the Crimean bridge hit by recent Ukrainian strikes - a crucial road and rail route for Russian soldiers heading towards the front line - Putin called it a "purely a civilian facility" and warned of a "much more painful" response
    • He also said Russia has extended an invitation to Moscow to European leaders to clarify what they "would bring to the negotiating table"
    • Reflecting on comparisons between today's trilateral meeting and the 1945 Yalta conference, he asked: "What was wrong with Yalta? What was so bad about it?"
    • Asked by the BBC whether the meeting was just a photo opportunity, Putin called it a serious endeavour and a useful format - but added that no overly ambitious goals had been set
  11. Analysis

    Big questions remain on Europe's role in Ukraine peace talkspublished at 13:22 GMT

    Liza Fokht
    BBC News Russian

    One of the big issues to follow after Putin's visit to China is the relationship between Russia and Europe.

    After meeting Vladimir Putin in Moscow last week, Trump's son-in-law and one of his main point people in dealings with the Kremlin, Jared Kushner, said Russia had agreed to include Europe in the next round of talks to end the war in Ukraine.

    But what we heard from Putin today suggests otherwise. According to him, the Kremlin has so far merely extended an invitation to European representatives to come to Moscow, so Russia can understand their position and decide whom it wants to see at the negotiating table.

    One can't help but wonder where this apparent discrepancy comes from. Was Kushner's statement an attempt to put pressure on Moscow, or did it reflect a genuine misunderstanding of the Russian leader's position?

    And if it's the latter, how much confidence can we have in these negotiations delivering results on the far more complicated questions of Ukraine's security and future?

    Some of these questions are likely to be addressed during today's high-stakes diplomatic talks in Berlin, where Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky will meet with European leaders and US President Donald Trump's envoys, Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff.

  12. Ukraine's allies set to meet Zelensky in Berlin 'mega-summit'published at 13:06 GMT

    Paul Kirby
    Europe digital editor

    Police officers provide security ahead of the summit of the so-called "Coalition of the Willing" group of pro-Ukrainian countries, outside the Chancellery, with the Reichstag Building in the background, in Berlin, Germany, November 19Image source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    There's high security for Thursday's summit at Merz's chancellery

    Hard on the heels of the Shenzhen trilateral meeting comes a "mega-summit" in Berlin involving 40 countries at Friedrich Merz's chancellery.

    This meeting of the "Coalition of the Willing" is aimed at agreeing financial support and security guarantees for Ukraine and giving a strong signal that Europe wants to be part of future talks on ending the war.

    Ukraine's Volodymr Zelensky has just arrived in the German capital for the summit, which also includes UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham, France's Emmanuel Macron and US negotiators Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff.

    Zelensky said last night that Witkoff and Kushner would give a "debrief" on what just happened at the trilateral summit in Shenzhen. According to Russian state media, Witkoff and Kushner have already taken part in a Shenzhen call with Russian and Chinese officials.

    On the surface, these two events have little in common, but more than anything it gives Ukraine's strongest allies a platform to react fast to what they have just heard from China.

  13. What can Europe bring to Ukraine negotiations? Putin askspublished at 12:59 GMT

    Liza Fokht
    BBC News Russian

    Wide shot of a conference room, Vladimir Putin standing at its centre speaking, two Russian flags behind him. At the forefront of the picture are several members of the press sitting down on white chairsImage source, EPA

    Vladimir Putin says Russia had sent invitations through diplomatic channels to European capitals, asking representatives to come to Moscow to clarify their positions on Ukraine.

    Putin is asked whether he was prepared to see Europeans at the negotiating table as part of the Russia-Ukraine-US format.

    According to the Russian leader, the White House has been “insisting” on European participation.

    He says that negotiations on Ukraine would inevitably touch on broader European security issues, which, in his words, would be “pointless” to discuss without Europe.

    However, Putin stops short of confirming that Europeans would take part in the negotiations.

    He says Russia needs to understand “what Europe would bring to the negotiating table.”

    According to Putin, this is why European representatives have been invited to Moscow.

  14. Putin faces BBC questions about joint declaration on peace as war in Ukraine continuespublished at 12:50 GMT

    BBC Russia correspondent Steve Rosenberg standing up speaking into a mic, a bloc of papers held in his left hand
    Image caption,

    BBC Russia editor Steve Rosenberg asked Putin whether signing the declaration on peace means Moscow will end the war with Ukraine

    The BBC's Steve Rosenberg has posed some questions to Putin, firstly asking if the trilateral meeting signals a new format for discussing global security, a new world order or was it just a photo opportunity?

    Secondly, he asks about the declaration on peace Putin issued with Xi and Trump - describing it as contradictory and asking if Russia will then put an end to the conflict in Ukraine.

    Putin jokingly asks whether Trump put him up to asking the question.

    He goes on to say the trilateral meeting was a serious endeavour and it was agreed that the format was a useful one but no overly ambitious goals had been set. He adds there was no agreement to regularly hold meetings in that format.

    On stopping conflict with Ukraine, he challenges the idea that Russia is the aggressor citing attacks on the Crimea bridge and Russian energy facilities.

    Putin says it's up to the Ukrainian side to put an end to the war and to make compromises.

  15. Putin: 'What was wrong with Yalta? What was so bad about it?'published at 12:30 GMT

    Liza Fokht
    BBC News Russian

    Putin speaks at press conferenceImage source, EPA

    Vladimir Putin has finally directly addressed comparisons between his meeting with Trump and Xi Jinping and the 1945 Yalta Conference, where the leaders of the Soviet Union, Britain and the US met towards the end of World War II.

    Judging by his comments, he doesn't seem to mind the comparison.

    "What was wrong with Yalta? What was so bad about it?"

    "At Yalta, the victory over Nazism was codified... I wouldn't mind - in fact, I would consider it right - to codify a victory over 'neo-Nazism' as well," Putin says.

    The Russian president also argues that the Yalta Conference created the conditions "under which the UN was established".

    "And for 80 years, thanks to those agreements, the world has lived without major global upheavals. There have been many regional conflicts, yes, but no global ones. What's wrong with that?" Putin says.

    Finally, he addresses suggestions that the three leaders had gathered in China to "divide up the world".

    "Nobody divided up the world at Yalta. It simply codified the realities that had emerged after World War II."

    "And when it comes to today's conflicts, the realities on the ground will have to be accepted," Putin says in what appears to be a clear reference to the war in Ukraine.

  16. Putin says Crimea bridge 'purely a civilian facility'published at 12:24 GMT

    Vladimir Putin now comments on the bridge connecting Russia and occupied Crimea, which Russia says was attacked again ahead of the trilateral talks.

    He says he had discussed a possible ceasefire in a number of areas under Russian control but after repeated attacks on the bridge, no negotiation will take place.

    "We do not use this bridge to transport military equipment or to move any military goods, even oil and oil products," Putin says. "This is purely a civilian facility."

    He says Russia will "respond" to the attacks, warning that "our response measures will be much more painful".

    An image from 17 November showing the Crimea bridge before and after a recent Ukrainian attack. Russia built the road and rail crossing after its illegal annexation of the Ukrainian peninsulaImage source, AFP via Getty Images
    Image caption,

    An image from 17 November showing the Crimea bridge before and after a recent Ukrainian attack. Russia built the road and rail crossing after its illegal annexation of the Ukrainian peninsula

  17. Russia has advantage on peaceful use of nuclear power - Putinpublished at 12:19 GMT

    Vladimir Putin mid-speech behind a portable wooden lectern, two Russian flags flanking himImage source, Reuters

    Putin says the trilateral meeting at the summit in Shenzhen addressed UN reform, security issues and nuclear non-proliferation.

    He says his country has an advantage on the nuclear issue as it is a leader in nuclear technology and the peaceful use of nuclear energy.

    On Russia's relations with the US, Putin says they could be improved, but added that the Trump administration's approach towards Moscow gave cause for optimism

  18. Putin claims Kyiv and Europe not ready to compromise yetpublished at 12:13 GMT

    Putin continues, saying that the meeting was "open" and "very useful".

    He says: "The discussion took place in a completely open atmosphere, which allowed us to understand one another better. Overall, it was very useful."

    On the issue of Ukraine, he says Kyiv and Europe are not yet ready to make compromises to resolve the conflict.

    News agency Ria Novosti also reports that Putin has expressed confidence that Trump genuinely seeks to resolve the Ukrainian conflict and to restore relations between Russia and the United States.

  19. Meeting with Xi and Trump an 'important chapter in history of diplomacy', says Putinpublished at 12:10 GMT

    Liza Fokht
    BBC News Russian

    Putin describes his meeting with Xi and Trump as an "important chapter in the history of diplomacy" and says it was of historic significance.

    On a number of key issues, the three leaders reached, if not agreements, then at least a mutual understanding, he adds.

  20. Putin addresses media after trilateral meetingpublished at 12:02 GMT

    Russian President Vladimir Putin speaks at a press conference following trilateral meetingImage source, Reuters

    Russian President Vladimir Putin is currently addressing the media following the trilateral meeting with China and the US earlier.

    We've got reporters in the room and will bring you the key lines - stick with us.