Summary

  • The state of NHS Grampian was raised at FMQs, prompting John Swinney to say that fresh allegations are of the "gravest concern"

  • Thursday's Q&A came days after Health Secretary Angela Constance made a statement in the Scottish Parliament about leadership failings at the health board

  • Hours before FMQs, a surgeon went public about the unnecessary deaths of patients following surgeries at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary

  • Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra accused the FM of knowing how bad the situation was and did "nothing". He went on to urge the Lord Advocate to launch a criminal prosecution

  • Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay echoed those words, arguing that Swinney was told three times about the "industrial scale" problems and did "nothing"

  • When Swinney was asked if he would have an operation at the Aberdeen Royal Infirmary he said "yes", adding that patients should be confident that their safety was of paramount importance

  • Scotland's UK Reform leader Malcolm Offord asked the FM about the "crisis" of young people not in work; Scottish Green leader Gillian Mackay asked about NHS Grampian and data centres and Scottish Lib Dem leader Alex Cole-Hamilton raised the problematic IT systems used at GP surgeries and by other public bodies

  • Watch live by clicking on the play button above

  1. FMQs: Key pointspublished at 15:00 GMT 19 November

    That's all for this week's First Minister's Questions. The key points were:

    • The state of NHS Grampian was raised, prompting John Swinney to say that fresh allegations were of the "gravest concern".
    • Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra accused the government of "systemic failure" and urged the lord advocate to launch a criminal prosecution.
    • Scottish Conservatives leader Russell Findlay echoed those words, arguing that Swinney was told three times about the "industrial scale" problems and did "nothing".
    • When Swinney was asked if he would have an operation at the Aberdeen Royal Infirmary he said "yes", adding that patients should be confident that their safety was of paramount importance
    • Reform UK's leader in Scotland, Malcolm Offord, asked the FM about the "crisis" of young people not in work
    • Scottish Greens leader Gillian Mackay asked about NHS Grampian and data centres, and the use of AI on SNP social media pages.
    • Scottish Lib Dem leader Alex Cole-Hamilton raised concerns about a new IT system being implemented by GP surgeries.

    Thanks for joining us. This page was edited by Catherine Lyst and the writers were Megan Bonar and Benjamin Russell.

  2. Analysis

    McKee will have his work cut out over sweeping reformspublished at 14:55 GMT 19 November

    Phil Sim
    Scotland political correspondent

    Like Gillian Mackay, Alex Cole-Hamilton felt he had to nod to NHS Grampian at the start of his questions, before pivoting on to another topic.

    The Lib Dem leader picked up on a question that one of his MSPs put to Swinney at backbench FMQs on Tuesday - the new computer system for GP practices, Vision.

    Cole-Hamilton said the software was “riddled with bugs” and was causing problems for patients and staff, saying the rollout should be paused.

    Swinney repeatedly answered that a new system had to be put in place and that work was ongoing to support practices.

    Over the first minister’s shoulder, Ivan McKee - the minister leading public service reform - had his nose buried in a folder of documents, apparently getting on with some work.

    This latest IT trouble is a reminder that even small changes can prove incredibly difficult to actually deliver. McKee will have his work cut out with the far more sweeping reforms planned for everything from health boards to local councils.

  3. We are supporting GP practices says Swinneypublished at 14:55 GMT 19 November

    Cole-Hamilton says GPs in Wales abandoned the same system after they experienced issues.

    He asks the FM to guarantee that no more surgeries will switch to the new system until the issues are “ironed out”.

    Swinney says there had to be a new system put in place.

    Swinney says the government is “supporting GP practices” in addressing the issues and ensuring there is continuity of care.

  4. Cole-Hamilton calls GP systems problems a 'fresh scandal'published at 14:54 GMT 19 November

    Alex Cole-Hamilton

    Scottish Lib Dem leader Alex Cole-Hamilton says he wants to warn the chamber about a “fresh scandal” in GP surgeries.

    He says “right now there are fewer appointments available to patients due to a faulty computer system”.

    He says GP's all over Scotland are having problems, with some only able to offer emergency appointments. Cole-Hamilton says it is a “nightmare for GPs” and is not only an IT scandal but a human one too.

    Swinney says the problems are arising from the fact that the old programme is coming to the end of its life and a new one is being rolled out.

  5. Analysis

    Opposition clearly feel the government still has questions to answerpublished at 14:52 GMT 19 November

    Lynsey Bews
    BBC Scotland political correspondent

    Russell Findlay begins by focusing in on the impact on patients, and those who may be due to receive treatment at NHS Grampian.

    Then he quickly turns to the same line of questioning pursued by Michael Marra - namely how long the Scottish government knew about what was happening within the health board, and the action it took.

    Findlay also accuses Swinney's government of protecting the board's leadership - and then comes that word - "cover-up".

    Opposition parties clearly feel the government still has questions to answer, even as the FM tries hard to give reassurances.

  6. Failure rewarded - Findlaypublished at 14:51 GMT 19 November

    Findlay goes on to say that whistblowers were not just ignored by the government, but John Swinney was warned “personally” at least three times, adding that “he did nothing.”

    Swinney says the appropriate areas of government looked at concerns with the relevant bodies.

    He adds that on questions around the wider performance of NHS Grampian, the government had intervened on various occasions and had put additional measures in place which led to this year's report.

    “This is what John Swinney’s Scotland looks like," Findlay says. "Patients died, families lied to. Whistleblowers destroyed. Failure rewarded.”

  7. More concerns over NHS Grampianpublished at 14:47 GMT 19 November

    Russell Findlay

    Scottish Tory leader Russell Findlay also raises concerns over NHS Grampian, asking the first minister if he would have any concerns about being treated at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary if he “required surgery there tomorrow”.

    Swinney says he wouldn’t have concerns and encouraged people to be “confident in the delivery of NHS services in Scotland, and specifically in NHS Grampian.

    The Conservative leader says people are concerned, and highlights that whistleblowers have been ignored by the SNP government.

    Swinney says “where concerns have been expressed they have been pursued.”

    He says the steps and individuals that have been put in place means that “confidence could be assured.”

  8. Analysis

    Data centres policy likely to be carefully weighed uppublished at 14:38 GMT 19 November

    Phil Sim
    Scotland political correspondent

    The NHS Grampian story has been unavoidable at Holyrood today, and Gillian Mackay nodded to it in her first question to John Swinney.

    But the Scottish Green co-leader swiftly pivoted to AI data centres, following on from a protest against them in Edinburgh last weekend.

    The government is due to publish planning guidance for local authorities, and Mackay was keen to make sure that is done with a measure of fanfare, with a ministerial statement before Holyrood breaks up for Christmas.

    The first minister agreed readily to that, but it sounds like the policy itself will be carefully weighed up.

    While he highlighted some concerns of his own about artificial intelligence, he also pointed to positive impacts in fields like the NHS.

    The shape of that guidance when it comes will be a fascinating test of how exactly the Scottish government wants to position itself and the nation as a whole when it comes to future industries.

  9. Mackay asks about AIpublished at 14:36 GMT 19 November

    Mackay goes on to ask about plans for AI data centres.

    She says more than 6,000 people took to the streets to protest over the issue last week. She asks when the government will make its planning guidance on data centres public.

    Swinney says he “recognises the level of public concern” about the issue and it will be published before the Christmas recess.

    Mackay says the SNP angered anti-AI campaigners by posted AI content on social media.

    Swinney says he does not want to offend anyone and says he understands the concerns about AI but equally he sees how the use of AI is advancing cancer care, for example.

  10. Can patients have confidence? Mackaypublished at 14:35 GMT 19 November

    Gillian Mackay

    Scottish Greens co-leader Gillian Mackay is up next.

    She also goes on NHS Grampian, asking what the government is doing in the short term to ensure patients are receiving “safe healthcare that they can have confidence in”.

    Swinney says the government will “build on the steps already taken”. He says this will include having an NHS professional as chairperson of the board.

    He says he hopes the actions by the government and dedication of healthcare professionals will address the “legitimate concerns”.

  11. Analysis

    FM accuses Offord of 'divisive rhetoric'published at 14:34 GMT 19 November

    Phil Sim
    Scotland political correspondent

    Malcolm Offord’s questions, as ever, dotted around a couple of different subjects, but with a unifying theme - that of people who have been “left behind”.

    From homelessness to youth unemployment, the Reform UK leader argued that this is a crisis.

    And he illustrated how his party has a very different answer to that of the SNP and Labour - while those parties are talking about rejoining the EU, Offord insisted that doing so would see “outsiders” taking opportunities away from Scots.

    Swinney’s initial answer was familiar from his government’s broader responses to the UK government’s Milburn review; a fairly pragmatic promise to look carefully at how to best support young people.

    But once things turned to the spikier issue of immigration, the tone became more confrontational too, with the first minister accusing Offord of “divisive” rhetoric - and again refusing to take forward any talks with Reform when it comes to the budget or anything else

  12. Still work to do - Swinneypublished at 14:34 GMT 19 November

    Swinney says he recognises the importance of the issues that Malcolm Offord raises, but saysthe activity rates among 16-24 year olds are higher in Scotland than the UK.

    He adds that this gives him “some encouragement that the steps we are taking are proving better outcomes for young people.”

    He says there is still work to do, and would see if there are other steps to take to make sure young people “had the best start in life and the best opportunity to participate in the economy”.

    Offord says it is unacceptable that 55,000 young Scots aren’t working and describes it as a crisis - regardless of what is happening in other parts of the UK.

    He then hits out at suggestions that rejoining the EU would help.

    “To allow a flood of 100,000 young EU migrants to gobble up the vacancies that our own young people need.”

    He asks the first minister why he would take away the “starter jobs from our own young Scots?”

  13. Background: What does the Milburn report mean for Scotland?published at 14:25 GMT 19 November

    Alan Milburn is wearing a suit, shirt and tie and glasses. His hand is raisedImage source, PA Media
    Image caption,

    Alan Milburn wants to reform employment support across the UK

    A major review has proposed widespread changes to tax, welfare and education to help get young people into work.

    The author, former Labour minister Alan Milburn, says his diagnosis of the problem applies UK-wide - yet the vast bulk of his report relates only to England.

    The report doesn't mention Scotland at all until page 93, and even then only in passing.

    It is another 100 pages before he notes that education, skills, health and local government are devolved to Edinburgh, Cardiff and Belfast.

    Across the UK, almost one million people aged 16 to 24 are not in education, employment or training (Neet) - a rate of 13% - according to the Office for National Statistics.

    Milburn wants to cut this to 5% within a decade.

    He says the UK and devolved governments "should agree common definitions, a shared set of headline outcomes and a regular joint review of progress".

    He also says they should consider the "further decentralisation or alignment of reserved youth employment support".

    Read more.

  14. Rising youth unemployment - Offordpublished at 14:24 GMT 19 November

    Offord thanks the first minister for his answers and agrees that there is a lack of up-to-date information on the problem.

    Citing the Milburn Report, he adds that one of the best ways to prevent homelessness among young people is to get them into employment.

    He says that in 2020 the SNP made a “young person’s guarantee called No-one Left Behind”.

    Offord adds that since then, unemployment among 16-24-year-olds has doubled to 55,000.

    He asks what the first minister says to those young Scots who “have been left behind”.

  15. Offord asks how many Scots are homeless?published at 14:23 GMT 19 November

    Malcolm Offord

    Next up is Malcolm Offord, Reform UK's leader in Scotland, with a question about homelessness.

    He asks if, with the weather turning colder, the first minster knows “how many of our fellow Scots are presently sleeping on the streets?”

    John Swinney says he doesn’t “have an accurate number” and says it is “difficult to establish precisely".

    However, he adds that the Scottish government is taking a number of steps to tackle the issue, including investing in the “creation of housing infrastructure to ensure the needs of the population are met within Scotland.”

  16. Analysis

    'Who knew what and when?'published at 14:21 GMT 19 November

    Lynsey Bews
    BBC Scotland political correspondent

    It felt inevitable that the new whistleblower revelations about NHS Grampian would be raised today.

    As MSPs across the chamber listened intently, Michael Marra honed in on what the first minister himself knew of what was happening within the health board.

    The Scottish Labour leader seized on the fact that Dr Habib wrote to ministers on several occasions.

    He called for the permanent secretary to investigate, with an internal review.

    This is becoming about "who knew what and when?".

    John Swinney's language is pretty sobering - describing the whistleblower's remarks as of the "gravest concern".

    He points to the significant improvements expected from the health board, and changes in leadership.

    But ministers are ultimately accountable - the buck stops at the very top - and it wouldn't be surprising if another party leader returns to this issue to challenge Swinney further.

  17. Background: 'Dramatic action' needed after NHS Grampian leaders criticised in damning report - Swinneypublished at 14:18 GMT 19 November

    L-R: Laura Skaife-Knight, chief executive; Paul Bachoo, former acute medical director; Dr June Brown, former executive nurse director; Dr Adam Coldwells, former interim chief executive; Dr Hugh Farrow Bishop, former executive medical directorImage source, BBC/NHS Grampian
    Image caption,

    L-R: Laura Skaife-Knight, chief executive; Paul Bachoo, former acute medical director; Dr June Brown, former executive nurse director; Dr Adam Coldwells, former interim chief executive; Dr Hugh Farrow Bishop, former executive medical director

    First Minister John Swinney has called for "dramatic action" to be taken after a healthcare watchdog issued a damning report into failures by senior leadership at NHS Grampian.

    Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) found "major deficiencies" across the region and revealed that a failure to learn from mistakes had caused "repeated and unavoidable harm" to patients.

    It also said it had lost confidence in management to deliver reliable and consistent information after Dr Gray's Hospital in Elgin continued to operate on children despite an order to halt all paediatric surgery.

    NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight said the board accepted the findings and apologised to patients.

    Speaking at First Minister's Questions last week, Swinney said the report made an "appalling read" and immediate changes had been made to the senior leadership.

    "It was crystal clear that the requirements to end surgery for children at Dr Gray's Hospital was not followed by NHS Grampian and that is reprehensible," the first minister told the chamber.

    "It is unacceptable that arrangements that should have been stopped for proper patient safety reasons were not stopped."

    Read more.

  18. Marra calls for urgent internal reviewpublished at 14:18 GMT 19 November

    Marra calls for an “urgent internal review” to look at who knew what, and when in the Scottish government.

    "Hundreds of grieving families will be wondering today" if it was their family member who “died needlessly”, he says. He adds that the first minister must act today to get those families answers.

    Swinney says the government acted last week to address the issues in the healthcare report.

    "These are issues that must be properly addressed by those in operational control of NHS Grampian," Swinney says.

    On criminal prosecution he says it is for the police and lord advocate to decide.

  19. Systemic failure - Marrapublished at 14:13 GMT 19 November

    John Swinney
    Image caption,

    John Swinney says the government is taking steps to ensure changes are made at the health board

    “I’m afraid that just does not wash,” Marra says.

    “Families were not told, the public were not told, but the first minister was told,” he says.

    Marra says the government had been told four times by Dr Habib – three times to the FM - but nothing was done.

    He accuses the government of “systemic failure” and claims they buried a report into the problems.

    The first minister says the issues were addressed to NHS Grampian and therefore are their responsibility but the government is taking steps to ensure changes are made at the health board.

  20. Tip of the iceberg - Marrapublished at 14:06 GMT 19 November

    Michael Marra

    Marra asks the first minister why 19 people have been allowed to die at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary.

    It comes after whistleblower Dr Mohammed Habib, a surgeon at the hospital, said he had been raising concerns for years.

    Marra says the “horrific revelations” revealed last week “were the tip of the iceberg”.

    Swinney says the issues raised by Habib are of the “gravest of concern”.

    The first minister says it is important that all concerns are properly pursued and that NHS Grampian has to “undertake very significant change”.