FMQs: Key pointspublished at 15:00 GMT 19 November
That's all for this week's First Minister's Questions. The key points were:
- The state of NHS Grampian was raised, prompting John Swinney to say that fresh allegations were of the "gravest concern".
- Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra accused the government of "systemic failure" and urged the lord advocate to launch a criminal prosecution.
- Scottish Conservatives leader Russell Findlay echoed those words, arguing that Swinney was told three times about the "industrial scale" problems and did "nothing".
- When Swinney was asked if he would have an operation at the Aberdeen Royal Infirmary he said "yes", adding that patients should be confident that their safety was of paramount importance
- Reform UK's leader in Scotland, Malcolm Offord, asked the FM about the "crisis" of young people not in work
- Scottish Greens leader Gillian Mackay asked about NHS Grampian and data centres, and the use of AI on SNP social media pages.
- Scottish Lib Dem leader Alex Cole-Hamilton raised concerns about a new IT system being implemented by GP surgeries.
Thanks for joining us. This page was edited by Catherine Lyst and the writers were Megan Bonar and Benjamin Russell.









