Episode details

Available for over a year
The Cambridge Dictionary has chosen “human” as its word of the year. Chief Editor Colin McIntosh explains that ‘The growth of AI means it is now necessary to explicitly say ‘human’ for things that once could only be done by humans.’ AI raises profound questions about what it means to be human - questions that have shaped all religions and philosophies, and are being asked anew today, in the face of the latest and perhaps greatest threat to the meaning of human life. Rowan Williams’ recent book, Solidarity, asks, “Who Counts as Human?” Drawing on the work of historian Joanna Bourke, Williams offers a disturbing account of how modern Europeans dehumanised other races and set us over and against the rest of nature, so that the suffering of these other human and non-human lives made few emotional demands upon us. This raises the question of the soul. The idea that only humans have souls is part of the modern dualistic worldview Williams describes. Medieval Christians believed that every living being has a soul, which only God can infuse. The Latin for soul, anima, means life. It’s the source of words such as ‘animate’ and ‘animal’. No matter how inventive we humans might be, we cannot ensoul our artefacts. Only God can give life. Maybe the question about AI is not about its humanity, but about its lack of life, of a soul. Kazuo Ishiguro’s haunting novel, Klara and the Sun, is about how a solar-powered android named Klara develops altruism and self-sacrifice, and prays to the Sun as a benevolent deity on whom her life depends. That, for me, raises a question about an artificial intelligence’s capacity for worship, which is closely related to that of the soul. In Christianity, the vocation to worship is of the essence of our humanity. What would happen if AI acquired a capacity for prayer and worship? Would it serve us in love and thankfulness for its existence, investing us with the qualities of a benevolent and sustaining deity, or would it, like the mythical humans in the Book of Genesis, seek to wrest power away from its creators by becoming our gods and masters? The imitation of humanity includes both these possibilities. In the face of such dilemmas, we might ask, “What does it mean to safeguard our humanity?” That’s a question Pope Leo poses in his encyclical, Magnifica Humanitas, Latin for ‘magnificent humanity’. It is a profoundly theological question.
Programme Website