BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

28 October 2014

BBC Homepage

Local BBC Sites

Neighbouring Sites

Related BBC Sites


Contact Us

Other Business

You are in: Jersey > Inside the States > Other Business > Pay to recycle at home?

Recycling

Pay to recycle at home?

Would you recycle if it was collected alongside your rubbish? Would you be prepared to pay more for the privilege?

Door step collections of recycling in Jersey would cost tax payers a huge amount of money according to the minister for Transport and Technical services.

Deputy Guy de Faye told BBC Jersey's talkback programme that it's cheaper to burn waste than recycle it.

He said that: "I'm very happy to take certain items out of the waste stream and I prefer they wouldn't go into the incinerator - what we call waste electricals are one such waste item.

"Getting rid of these things in a responsible way costs £500 per tonne and that is very dramatically more than the cost of burning things in an incinerator."

But the chairman of the Environment Scrutiny Panel, Deputy Rob Duhamel, says the costings of recycling are from a report from Wales and aren't sound figures.

He told BBC Jersey: "If you've got such a wide variation, such a wide spread between the values they are not to be taken out of context. Quiet clearly the department have done that in order to try to promote the idea that material recycling facilities are expensive to run. They're not."

Have your say

Would you be more likely to recycle if the separate items were collected from your doorstep instead of you having to take them to a collection point?

Do you already recycle? If so why? Would you recycle more if it was made easier to do? Would you be prepared to pay higher rates if it meant you could recycle without having to go to a recycling point?

last updated: 07/07/2008 at 13:18
created: 07/07/2008

Have Your Say

The BBC reserves the right to edit comments submitted.

Richard
what is re-cycling? what can you re-cycle in Jersey? what is re-cycled in Jersey?

Scott
I recently visited a friend in nottingham where they have a fantastic recycling scheme being run by the council. Each household receives 2 large bins (green & brown), 1 plastic container (which fits into the large brown one), 1 medium bin (peddle bin size), and 1 small bin (size of a ice cream tub). large green bin is for non recyclable general waste (collected fortnightly), the brown bin (cardboard, paper, cans, plastic) is collected fornightly between the green bin collection. The brown container is for glass, collected with the brown bin. The small bin is for food waste (they even provide special biodegradable bags to put your food in) this is collected same time as your regular waste. The small bin is for convenience to be kept in your kitchen and again for food waste. My friends really enjoy the recycling, and I was completely amazed at the amount of recyclable materials they are able to provide. So much so, that they now use regular carrier bags (rather than large bin liners) for general waste: because the amount is very limited due to recycling. If ever there is a scheme for the States to employ, then look no further than Nottingham

Anita
I live at Havre Des Pas and wehave been recycling for a number of years. We are a family of 5 and we are amazed what we do recycle in a week. Normally it is one crate of paper, one crate of cardboard, at least 3-4 big, big bags of plastic and at least 1 big bag of cans. It takes some getting use to but it is second nature to us now, but I know what you mean about people being too lazy. My mum is not interested in recycling, like she said why bother when the states have got this big new incinerator!!!!!

Kneoprene
I already recycle by taking materials to the bring banks but I'm fearful of doorstep collections because there are some in this Island who are too lazy or ill-disciplined to cope. Some of my neighbours generate two large bin fulls of waste per week - that's from a family of 4- but won't buy a second bin. You can imagine how much fun seagulls are having tearing up their uncovered black bags and littering the surrounding area. Before we get too ambitious with a population that isn't totally ready why not try some smaller things that can make a big difference? I loved Deputy Judy Martin's idea that she came out with in the States yesterday. Those of us who want to recycle more should strip off the excess packaging from products we buy and leave it in the shop. In the long run we might get less waste arriving here in the first place.

You are in: Jersey > Inside the States > Other Business > Pay to recycle at home?



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy