BBC BLOGS - The Devenport Diaries

Archives for August 20, 2007

Iris and the F Word

Mark Devenport|15:04 UK time, Monday, 20 August 2007

Comments

It's taken a bit of time for the transcripts of some of the Stormont committee sessions to appear on the Assembly website but in the case of the Health Committee's trip to Magee College at the end of June it's been worth the wait.

MLAs were cross questioning Health Department officials on their draft Sexual Violence strategy when the chair, Iris Robinson, espoused some forthright views on the need for the media to "curtail material that feeds minds that may commit sexual or copycat crimes".

The Strangford MP went on to accuse TV bosses of broadcasting "the most violent filth that you could ever wish to see before the watershed...With the greatest respect to anybody who is a fan, programmes such as ‘Emmerdale, ‘ Coronation Street’, and ‘EastEnders’ try to outdo one another in graphic storylines. They portray bed-hopping and sexual promiscuity to which children are exposed because they are broadcast before the watershed. Such programmes are good at highlighting certain themes and illnesses such as AIDS, but they do not deal with the main issue; they are saying, “Such behaviour is normal”. We do not hear about prevention or about having a lifelong love partner."

Without naming Gordon Ramsay, she went on to lambast "a chef whose every other word is the F word". She finished by declaring "I do not care if I am called a “Mary Whitehouse”; indeed, I wish there were more such people, and it is sad that she passed away."

I think someone should tell mediawatch, the successor body to the National Viewers and Listeners Association, that six years after the passing of their founder, Mrs Whitehouse, a new scourge of the media has rallied to her cause.



How to libel a mole

Mark Devenport|14:28 UK time, Monday, 20 August 2007

Comments

I'm back in the office and I promise not to disappear for the foreseeable future. The obvious topic to discuss would be those press reports alleging a senior republican helped set up a police officer, Eric Lutton, for murder by the IRA in 1979, but escaped prosecution after being recruited by the security forces as an agent.

Maybe because I am still in cautious holiday mode, but more importantly because I don't have any independent evidence, I don't intend to follow the example of other blogs which have identified the alleged agent as a current Sinn Fein politician. Instead I shall hold off until the Upper Bann MP David Simpson does or does not use parliamentary privilege to name someone. The son of Mr Lutton has referred the matter to the Police Ombudsman. Sinn Fein say the story is a "DUP stunt". And I thought the two parties were best buddies.

If parliamentary privilege is invoked broadcasters and newspapers will be free to run with the name without fear of a libel action. But if you took parliamentary privilege out of the equation it's interesting to ponder where the libel risk would lie. According to McNae's "Essential Law for Journalists" (the standard textbook) you can libel someone if you lower them in "the estimation of right thinking members of society generally; or disparage them in their business, trade, office or profession"

If someone is a republican and you say they helped the IRA that presumably wouldn't lower them in the estimation of fellow republicans. But if you say they secretly worked for the state would that damage or enhance their standing amongst those a judge might regard as "right thinking members of society generally"?


BBC © 2014The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.